What is the best beef breed for dairy crosses?
It depends on your buyer
AMARILLO, Texas — There isn't one best beef breed for dairy crosses, but Angus is the most common choice, with continental breeds like Simmental, Charolais and Limousin used when the goal is more muscle and frame. The right answer depends on three things: how easily the sire's calves are born out of a dairy cow, what your calf buyer wants to feed and sell, and how the finished animal grades at the packing plant. Pick the breed after you've talked to the buyer, then pick the individual bull by data. Here's how to think it through.
Why Angus is the default
Angus sires are popular on dairy cows for a few reasons. Calves tend to be moderate in size at birth, black hides sort cleanly in the marketing channel, and the breed has a long record of carcass marbling that fits how many U.S. packers pay for quality grade. Large numbers of Angus bulls have published performance data too, so you have plenty of choice.
That doesn't mean every Angus bull is a fit. Birth weight and calving ease numbers vary widely inside the breed. A bull that sires big, fast-growing calves on a beef cow could mean trouble on a dairy heifer.
If you don't know where to start, ask your semen supplier for sires with proven calving ease data and a record of use on dairy females, then check how their progeny have performed at feeding and harvest.
When continental breeds make sense
Simmental, Charolais, Limousin and similar breeds add growth, muscle and frame. Dairy calves tend to be light-muscled, so continental genetics can improve yield and carcass leanness. Some feeders like that the calf looks more like a conventional beef animal.
The tradeoff is that some continental sires produce bigger calves and more difficult births, and the calves may grade differently. Hide color can also affect price with certain buyers, so ask before you commit.
Crossbreeding systems like SimAngus mix both ideas, and some producers use those sires to split the difference. As with Angus, individual sire data matters more than the breed label. Look at calving ease, birth weight, growth, and carcass expected progeny differences, known as EPDs. The Nebraska beef extension and Kansas State's research and extension publish material on crossbreeding and sire selection you can use as a reference.
Match the sire to the cow
The cow in front of you matters as much as the breed. First-calf heifers and smaller-framed cows need the easiest calving sires available. Mature, larger cows can handle more growth. Holsteins, Jerseys and crossbred dairy cows all differ in pelvic size and in how their calves finish, and a Jersey cross calf is a different animal from a Holstein cross in the feedlot.
So you may want two or three sires on the shelf: an easy-calving bull for heifers, a growth bull for mature cows, and perhaps something specific for a buyer program. Label your straws and tanks clearly. It's amazing how many calving mistakes start in the semen tank.
Ask your buyer what they pay for
This is the step many herds skip. A calf buyer, feedlot or packer knows which crosses perform for them. Some programs reward a certain sire breed, color or carcass target, and others pay no premium at all. If no one pays extra for a particular breed in your region, the best choice is the one that calves easily and finishes well.
Ask three questions: what breed or type do you prefer, what do you discount, and what documentation do you want with the calf. Then watch the market prices at USDA AMS market news, since the price spread between types shifts over time. I won't give you current numbers here because they don't stay put.
Judge results, then adjust
After a calving season, record how each sire did: calving ease, calf vigor, health, weaning or sale weight, and what the buyer paid. Within a year or two you'll know whether Angus or a continental cross fits your cows and your market. The Beef Quality Assurance program can help you tighten up handling and documentation along the way.
If you want to compare dairy-beef results from a research viewpoint, look at the university beef programs and at Beef Research for management material. They'll give you ideas, but your own records will tell you which bull to reorder.
The short version
Start with a calving-ease Angus sire if you want the low-risk option, consider continental or composite sires on larger mature cows when your buyer pays for muscle, and let the actual calves from your own herd settle the argument. A bull with a famous name and a rough calving record is still a rough calving record.