What is the best brine ratio for cheese?

Salt, calcium and temperature

KENDALLVILLE, Indiana — Most cheese brines are built around a salt concentration somewhere in the high teens to low twenties by weight, and a fully saturated brine is the common starting point for many makers. There isn't one magic number, because the best brine depends on the cheese, the wheel size and the time you leave it in. A saturated brine, which holds as much salt as water can dissolve at that temperature, is steady and easy to reproduce. Many recipes then adjust the pH and add calcium so the brine doesn't pull minerals out of your cheese. Treat what follows as the general method and check your recipe for exact numbers.

Why saturated brine is popular

Salt dissolves only up to a limit, and once you hit it, extra salt sits on the bottom of the container. That makes a saturated brine self-correcting. As you pull cheese out and salt gets absorbed, the undissolved salt refills the water. A rough figure for saturation is in the low-to-mid twenties percent by weight at cool temperatures, though the real number shifts a bit with temperature.

A weaker brine works too. It just draws salt in more slowly and gives you more control on small or delicate cheeses.

Calcium chloride and pH

Plain salt water pulls calcium out of the cheese surface, which can leave the rind soft and weak. Many makers add a small amount of calcium chloride, often a fraction of a percent of the brine weight, to replace that loss. They also adjust the brine's pH toward the pH of the cheese, commonly using a mild acid like vinegar or citric acid. Specific amounts vary by recipe, so go with a trusted source rather than a guess.

A brine that is too alkaline compared to the cheese can cause surface slickness and uneven salting. A quick strip test helps.

Temperature and time

Brine is usually kept cool, in the same range as a cheese cave or a refrigerator, so the cheese doesn't warm up while it soaks. Warm brine speeds salting but also invites trouble.

Soak time depends mostly on size and style. A small wheel might brine for a few hours, and a large, dense wheel may sit for a day or longer. Many recipes give hours per pound or a range for the diameter. Flip the cheese partway through, and float a little salt on the exposed top so the surface doesn't go unsalted.

Keeping the brine clean

A brine is a reusable salty bath, and it can collect protein, fat and bacteria over time. Strain it, skim the top, and filter it periodically. Some makers boil and re-saturate it when it looks cloudy. Keep the container covered and out of the way of raw milk and floor splashes.

Never put a cheese in a brine with a questionable smell. Dump it, clean the vessel and start again. Salt is cheap, a lost batch isn't.

Brining small and large wheels

Size changes everything. A pound wheel can reach the salt level it needs in a few hours, while a big wheel can take a day or more, since salt travels through the paste slowly. Cheese that's brined too long ends up salty at the rind and bland in the center, then slowly evens out in the cave.

Some makers keep two brines, a lighter one for small or soft cheeses and a saturated one for large, firm wheels. Others brine for the same period every time and weigh the cheese before and after, which lets them track salt uptake in a simple way.

Float the wheels with a small plastic cover or sprinkle salt on top so the exposed surface salts too. Flip halfway through. Then drain and dry the surface before the cheese goes to the cave, so you don't start a slimy rind.

Check, test and learn more

Use a salinometer or a hydrometer if you want to confirm concentration, and use a scale to measure salt by weight instead of by cup, since salt grain size changes volume. For practical guides on small-scale dairy processing, try Penn State Extension and the University of Wisconsin farm resources. For safe food handling rules at a licensed facility, see the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service and your state dairy regulator.

If your brined cheese tastes flat or sharp, don't just change the ratio. Check brine time, cheese size and pH first.