What is the best way to benchmark a dairy?

Compare yourself to the right peers

STILLWATER, Minnesota — The best way to benchmark a dairy is to compare your own numbers with similar herds, using the same definitions, and to track your own trend over time. A comparison only helps if you're comparing like with like: similar size, housing, breed and region. Pick a handful of measures covering production, herd health, reproduction, heifers and finances, and look at them on a regular schedule. The goal isn't to be the best on every line. It's to find the one or two gaps that cost the most.

Choose the measures

Start small. Common choices include milk per cow, components, somatic cell count, pregnancy rate, calf and heifer death loss, age at first calving, feed cost per hundredweight, income over feed cost, labor efficiency, and total cost of production. Add herd turnover rate and treatment costs if you want a look at health. Make sure you calculate each number the same way every time. Write down the formula so you don't change it midyear.

Find comparison data

Financial benchmarks are available through farm business management programs run by universities and extension. The Center for Farm Financial Management maintains a farm financial database called FINBIN that lets you compare with similar farms. The USDA Economic Research Service publishes cost and return estimates for milk. Your DHI provider can show herd-level production and udder health comparisons, and your vet or nutritionist may have local averages. Cooperative and processor programs sometimes share quality benchmarks. Ask about the group size and method, because averages hide a lot of variety.

Compare within your group

Rank yourself against the top group, not the average. The average may be mediocre. Look at the spread: if you're in the middle on milk per cow but near the bottom on feed cost, that's where to look. Look at whether the top herds do something structural, like larger scale or a different housing setup, that you can't copy. Focus on management changes you can make.

Track your own trend

Benchmarking against yourself is often more useful. Chart your numbers monthly or quarterly. A slow rise in somatic cell count or a dip in pregnancy rate tells you something is changing before an outside comparison would. Mark management changes on the chart, like a new ration or a new hire, to see effects.

Turn it into action

Cost data is covered in Iowa State's ag decision maker, and farmdoc daily analyses of farm economics are worth reading. Take care with outlier farms in any benchmark group. One huge herd can pull averages around.

Benchmarks are a mirror, not a grade. Don't hide from the mirror, and don't redecorate before you know what's wrong.