What is the best way to budget with volatile prices?

Budget in ranges, not single numbers

PLATTEVILLE, Wisconsin — The best way to budget with volatile milk prices is to stop budgeting around one price. Build three versions of your budget: a conservative case, a middle case and an optimistic one, then decide ahead of time what you will do in each. A single-price budget will be wrong, and when it's wrong, it's usually wrong at the worst moment. Ranges turn surprises into plans.

Start with your cost of production

Before you can judge prices, know what it costs you to make a hundredweight of milk. Include feed, labor (including unpaid family labor at a fair rate), vet, supplies, utilities, repairs, depreciation, interest and taxes. Use your own records, not an average. Tools and training from the Center for Farm Financial Management and your extension service help, and farmdoc daily regularly covers dairy margins. Your break-even price is the foundation of every scenario.

Build three price scenarios

Pick a low, middle and high milk price. For the middle, use something close to recent experience or a conservative expectation. For the low, think about a bad stretch you have seen before, then go a bit lower. For the high, use a good but not rare year. Look at published prices through AMS Market News and the ERS dairy outlook to anchor the range. Avoid making up numbers based on how you feel this week.

Vary other inputs too

Prices of feed, fuel and interest rates also move. For each scenario, adjust feed costs and production assumptions. A low milk price plus high feed cost is the combination that hurts most, so test that pairing. Include the effect of risk programs: Dairy Margin Coverage through FSA and Dairy Revenue Protection through RMA change your outcomes in the low case, so model them with current terms from those agencies.

Set triggers and actions

For each scenario, write down what you will do. Examples:

Triggers make decisions easier because you made them when you were calm.

Build a reserve

A cash reserve is the simplest buffer. Even a small, steady contribution in good months helps. Keep it separate from operating cash so it doesn't get spent. If a reserve is not possible, consider a pre-arranged operating line of credit with your lender. Information on FSA lending is at farmers.gov/loans.

Review monthly and revisit quarterly

Compare actual results to your scenarios each month. Which one are you tracking? Update your assumptions at least quarterly. Share the budget with your lender, accountant and family partners so everyone knows the plan. The IRS Publication 225 helps with tax planning, which can affect cash flow and the timing of big purchases.

A practical note

Budgets don't predict the future; they prepare you for several versions of it. A farm that has already walked through the low case on paper handles it better in person. And if the high case shows up, you will have a plan for that too, which is a pleasant problem to have.