What is the best way to drain whey?
Match the method to the cheese
KEWAUNEE, Wisconsin — The best way to drain whey depends on the cheese. Soft and fresh cheeses drain by gravity through a cloth or in molds, firm cheeses drain while being stirred and pressed, and large batches can be ladled or poured through a colander. In every case, the goal is to remove whey at the right time, at the right temperature and at the right speed, because draining too fast or too slow changes texture and acidity. After draining, you also need a plan for the whey itself.
Fresh and soft cheeses
For ricotta, chevre, queso fresco and cream cheese, drain through a cloth-lined colander or hang the cloth in a bag. The longer it hangs, the drier the cheese. Stop when it reaches the texture you want. Bloomy rinds drain in molds over several hours and need flipping so they drain evenly. Never squeeze a soft curd hard, because that forces out fat and makes the cheese grainy.
Stirred-curd and cooked cheeses
For cheddar, gouda and many hard cheeses, whey comes out during cutting, stirring and cooking. You then drain it by pouring the pot through a colander or by ladling whey off the top before collecting the curd. Gouda-style cheeses drain part of the whey and replace it with warm water. Take whey off while the curd is still moving so it doesn't mat. Matted curd traps whey and gives a gummy interior.
Pressing
Pressing finishes the job. Light pressure first lets whey escape slowly. Heavy pressure too soon closes the surface and traps moisture. Flip and re-dress the cheese as whey flows. Use a tray or channel under the press to catch whey.
Tools that help
- Cheesecloth, butter muslin or fine mesh for fresh cheese.
- A ladle or slotted spoon for small batches.
- A colander lined with cloth for medium batches.
- Perforated molds for pressed cheese.
- A bucket or pot to collect whey.
What to do with the whey
Whey is a nuisance and an asset. It's rich in organic matter and can harm streams or septic systems if dumped. Don't pour large volumes into ditches, ponds or the household drain. Use it: make ricotta, feed it to pigs or poultry where appropriate, use it in baking, or apply it to land only under the rules that apply. Check with your state environmental or agriculture agency for guidance on land application and disposal. Whey spoils quickly, so cool it and use it within a day or two.
Resources
See Penn State Extension, ATTRA, NRCS for conservation and nutrient planning, and USDA AMS for local food rules.
Timing and temperature
Whey that drains too hot can dry the curd, and whey that drains too cold can leave it wet and unfinished. Follow the recipe's draining temperature and time, and keep a thermometer in the pot. Watch the curd as well as the clock. When the curd is firm, springy and settles quickly to the bottom, it's ready to drain. If it remains soft and milky, give it more time. Draining the whey in two stages, first pouring off most of it and then pressing the rest out, often gives cleaner results than one big rush.
A note on cloth
The cloth you use affects drainage. Fine butter muslin holds soft curds but drains slowly, while coarser cheesecloth drains faster and suits firmer curd. Wash cloths in hot water with unscented detergent, or just hot water, and dry them thoroughly. Soap residue or perfume can taint cheese. Replace cloths that tear or stay stained, and keep a few clean ones ready. Rinse a used cloth in cold water first, since hot water sets milk protein into the weave and leaves a gray film that is hard to remove. Hang cloths to dry in open air rather than folding them damp into a drawer, where they pick up musty smells that end up in your next cheese. Boil or sanitize them before each batch if your rules call for it, and write the date on the corner of any cloth that has seen a lot of use so you know when to retire it.
Whey drains faster than you expect, and then there are ten gallons of it staring back at you. Plan for that before you start.