What is the best way to feed dairy cows?
Consistent, balanced, always available
TULARE, California — The best way to feed dairy cows is to give them a consistent, balanced ration that they can eat whenever they want, in a clean bunk, with plenty of water. The exact recipe changes by stage of lactation, but the habits don't: same feeding times, same mix every day, and feed in front of them nearly all day.
Feed to the group, not the average cow
Dairy herds are usually split into groups: fresh cows, high producers, later lactation, dry cows and close-up cows. Each group has different needs for energy, protein, fiber and minerals. Feeding the same ration to everyone either shortchanges the high producers or overfeeds and fattens the late-lactation cows. A nutritionist can help set groups and rations, and your feed company may provide this service.
How many groups you can run depends on your barn and labor. Even splitting the herd into two groups can be a gain over one.
Total mixed ration versus other systems
A total mixed ration (TMR) combines forage, grain and supplements in a mixer so every bite is balanced. It helps stop cows from picking out the grain and ignoring the fiber. Other farms feed forage and grain separately, graze, or use parlor feeding or robots. Each works when managed well.
With a TMR, mixing order, mixing time, and particle size matter. A mix that's too long can pulverize the fiber, and a mix that's too short leaves chunks cows can sort. Ask your nutritionist to show you how to use a particle separator on the farm.
Bunk management
Cows eat many small meals. Push feed up often, keep the bunk full enough that cows rarely run out, and clean refusals daily. Target a small amount of leftover feed. Too much waste costs money, and too little means some cows aren't eating enough, especially lower-ranking ones.
Give enough bunk space so timid cows can eat. Overcrowding reduces intake. Shade the bunk where heat is a problem and feed at cooler times during hot spells.
Forage quality and testing
The ration is only as good as the forages in it. Test forages for dry matter, protein, fiber, digestibility and mold or mycotoxins if suspected, and retest when you open a new pile or bag. Dry matter changes with rain, and not adjusting for it means every batch is a little different. Regular dry matter checks on silage are cheap insurance.
For forage options, see the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and Wisconsin dairy extension, and the Dairy Cattle Nutrition information at extension.org. The Nutrient Management Council might help with whole-farm nutrient planning.
Water, minerals and cost watching
Water is the most-ignored nutrient. A cow needs a lot of it, so clean troughs and plenty of drinking space matter. Minerals and buffers need to be matched to your forage base and stage of lactation, so don't copy a neighbor's mineral mix.
Watch the numbers: milk per cow, milk components, body condition, manure consistency and feed cost per hundredweight. If milk dips with no obvious reason, check feed first. Feed mixing errors, a bad forage change or a clogged waterer are common causes.
Work with a nutritionist you trust and who will explain the reason behind each change. If you can't explain why the ration is what it is, that's a conversation worth having. Cows will eat almost anything once, but they'll only produce on what's good for them.