What is the best way to make cheddar?

Patience through cheddaring, milling, and pressing

GRAFTON, Wisconsin — The best way to make cheddar is to follow a tested recipe closely: culture the milk, set it with rennet, cut and cook the curd, drain, cheddar the slabs by stacking and turning them, mill, salt, press, and age for months. Cheddaring is the step that makes cheddar what it is, since stacking the curd slabs lets acid develop and whey drain, giving the dense, flaky texture. It's a long make, often most of a day, but each step is simple.

Gather your gear

You'll need a large stainless pot, a water bath or double boiler, a thermometer, a long knife or curd harp, a mold, a press, cheesecloth, and a pH meter if you have one. Use a mesophilic culture, non-ultra-pasteurized milk, rennet, and calcium chloride if your milk is pasteurized and homogenized.

Make the curd

  1. Warm the milk to the recipe's temperature and add culture, then let it ripen.
  2. Add diluted rennet and let the curd set until it gives a clean break.
  3. Cut the curd into small cubes, about a quarter to half inch.
  4. Stir and slowly raise the temperature, following your recipe, to firm the curd.
  5. Hold and stir until the curd reaches the right firmness and acid.
  6. Drain the whey.

Cheddar the curd

Pile the curd on a draining surface, press it into a mat, then cut the mat into slabs. Stack and turn the slabs periodically while keeping them warm. As the slabs knit, they lose whey and gain acid, and the texture shifts from rubbery to a flaky, chicken-breast-like feel. A pH meter helps you judge when the curd is ready to mill. This step can take an hour or two.

Mill and salt

Cut slabs into small pieces, often about the size of your thumb, and let them air out briefly. Add salt in portions, mixing gently, which slows acid and draws out more whey. Salt level strongly affects flavor and safety, so weigh it according to the recipe.

Press and age

  1. Pack salted curd into a cloth-lined mold.
  2. Press lightly at first, then increase weight over hours.
  3. Flip and re-dress the cheese as the recipe directs.
  4. Air-dry the cheese until the surface is dry.
  5. Wax, bandage, or vacuum-seal, then age in a cool, humid space.

Mild cheddar needs a few months, and sharp cheddar needs longer. Taste along the way.

Fixes for common problems

Time planning

Cheddar takes a full day, so plan your hours. A typical day includes a long ripening and setting stage, a cutting and cooking stage, a cheddaring stage that takes a couple of hours, then milling, salting, and pressing. Start in the morning so you aren't pressing at midnight. Keep your kitchen warm and your tools ready.

Aging and tasting

After pressing and drying, a young cheddar-style cheese often ages in a cool space for a few months. Taste a plug at the first milestone. If the texture is firm and the flavor mild but clean, you're on track. Sharp cheddar needs further months, and flavor grows as the proteins break down. Don't rush it. Keep a notebook entry for every wheel so you can repeat the one you love.

Equipment shortcuts

You don't need a purpose-built cheddar table. A clean sink rack, a food-safe tray, or a colander over a pot can hold curd slabs for cheddaring. Keep them warm with a covered pan of hot water nearby. A towel over the curd slows heat loss. Improvise safely, and sanitize anything that touches the curd.

Learn more

eXtension, the University of Wisconsin farm extension site, Penn State Extension, and Cornell small farms have dairy processing guidance. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service covers food safety.

Cheddar rewards patience and punishes shortcuts. Take notes, since next year's wheel will thank you.