What is the best way to make feta from goat milk?

Brined, tangy and crumbly

TAOS, New Mexico — The best way to make feta from goat milk is to keep it simple: culture the milk, set it with rennet, cut and gently stir the curd, drain it in a mold or cloth, cut it into slabs, salt it, and age it in brine. Goat milk makes a tangy, crumbly feta that is closer to the traditional character than many cow milk versions. The process takes a day of hands-on work and then a few weeks of brine aging. Below is a practical method, plus the places where batches tend to go wrong.

Start with good milk and clean gear

Feta shows off milk quality because it has little to hide behind. Use fresh goat milk, pasteurized if you plan to sell it or if you prefer lower risk, and avoid ultra-pasteurized milk. Many makers add a pinch of calcium chloride to pasteurized milk to improve curd firmness, following the package directions.

Sanitize the pot, thermometer, curd knife, ladle, molds and containers. A stainless steel pot and a long knife are enough to start. A cheese mold with drainage holes helps, though a colander lined with cloth can do the job.

Culture, set and cut

  1. Warm the milk to roughly 86°F.
  2. Add a mesophilic culture and let it work for a short ripening time.
  3. Stir in diluted rennet, then stop stirring and let the milk set undisturbed until it gives a clean break, which is when the curd splits cleanly around a finger.
  4. Cut the curd into roughly half-inch cubes with a long knife and let the cubes rest briefly.
  5. Stir gently for a period so the curds firm up in the whey.

Cutting size and stirring time control moisture. Smaller curds and longer stirring give a drier, firmer cheese. Larger curds keep more moisture and a softer texture.

Drain, press lightly and cut

Ladle the curds into a mold or cloth-lined colander and let whey drain, flipping once or twice. Don't press hard; feta should be crumbly but not dry. After several hours, when the cheese holds together, cut it into slabs or cubes.

Save the whey for ricotta, bread baking or feeding to livestock in measured amounts.

Salt and brine

Salt the slabs lightly on all sides, using non-iodized salt, and let them sit for some hours or overnight in the refrigerator or a cool space. Then move them to a container with brine. A typical brine is salt dissolved in water, with a small amount of calcium chloride and a splash of whey or mild acid in some recipes. Keep the cheese fully submerged.

Brine aging for a week or two gives you young feta, and longer aging gives a stronger, saltier cheese. Taste along the way. Store the container cold, and keep it covered.

Fix common feta problems

Record your timing and temperatures. A notebook beats memory every time.

Selling feta and finding help

If you plan to sell feta, check licensing with your state agriculture department first. Pasteurized cheese commonly needs a licensed facility and approved labels, and brine handling can raise questions of its own. The Agricultural Marketing Resource Center covers value-added dairy, ATTRA has small ruminant materials, and eXtension can point you toward workshops. For market access ideas, the USDA AMS local and regional food resources are worth a look.

Feta forgives more than most cheeses. It is salty, tangy and quick, and it ages in a bucket in your fridge, which is a lot easier than building a cave.