What is the best way to make manchego?
Sheep milk, firm press, patient aging
SANTA FE, New Mexico — The best way to make a manchego-style cheese is to start with whole sheep milk, set it with rennet and a mesophilic or mixed starter, cut the curd small, cook it gently, press it firmly in a mold, brine it and age it for at least two months, longer for a sharper, drier wheel. One thing to know: Manchego is a protected name for cheese made in a specific region of Spain from a particular breed of sheep, so cheese made elsewhere should be labeled something like sheep's milk cheese in the manchego style.
Why the milk matters
Sheep milk is high in fat and protein, which means high yield and rich flavor. A gallon of sheep milk can give considerably more cheese than a gallon of cow milk. It is also seasonal, with a lactation that comes and goes, so many sheep dairies freeze milk or time production around it. Use pasteurized milk or follow state rules for aging raw milk cheese. If you can't get sheep milk, cow or goat milk can make a firm pressed cheese, but it won't taste like manchego.
Set, cut and cook
Warm the milk to about 90 degrees Fahrenheit, add starter and rennet, and let the curd set until firm. Sheep milk sets quickly and firmly, so watch your timing. Cut the curd to small pieces, about the size of a grain of rice or small pea, and stir while slowly raising the temperature to roughly the low 100s Fahrenheit. A small curd and gentle cook leave a drier, firmer paste that ages well. Follow your chosen recipe for exact temperatures and times.
Press and mold
Pack the curd into a mold and press it, increasing weight in stages across several hours. The traditional wheel has a patterned rind from woven molds. You can get a similar look with a patterned follower or just accept a plainer rind. Press until the cheese is closed and holds a clean shape. Flip it and re-dress the cloth during pressing. A well-pressed wheel ages cleanly, while an under-pressed one traps moisture and cracks or bloats.
Brine and age
Soak the wheel in brine for a time based on its size, then dry it for a few days until the rind is firm. Age it at about 50 to 55 degrees Fahrenheit and moderate humidity. Wipe or brush the rind to manage mold, and flip it often. Young wheels at around two months are mild and supple; those aged six months or more become drier, nuttier and sharper. Many makers rub the rind with olive oil to protect the surface.
Check list for a good wheel
- Use clean, fresh milk and a verified starter.
- Keep the curd small and the cook gentle.
- Press in stages, not all at once.
- Control brine time and drying.
- Record weights, temperatures and aging so you can repeat success.
For breed and production background, see SheepUSA, ATTRA and Penn State Extension. If you plan to sell, check licensing and the 60-day aging rule for raw milk cheese through your state and federal rules.
Handling the rind
A traditional wheel is rubbed or washed during aging to keep the surface clean. Brush off dry mold, wipe the rind with a cloth dampened with light brine and rub in a thin coat of olive oil every so often. Flip the wheel at least weekly so moisture doesn't settle at the bottom. If the rind cracks, rub it with oil and increase humidity slightly. If it turns damp and sticky, add airflow. Keep sheep cheeses on clean wooden or plastic racks, never in direct contact with a dirty shelf. Taste a plug with a cheese trier around the two-month mark so that you can decide whether to keep aging, since each wheel is a little different.
A good manchego-style wheel rewards a year of planning. Your sheep won't care how long it takes.