What is the best way to make string cheese?
Stretch the curd, then chill it
SHEBOYGAN, Wisconsin — The best way to make string cheese is to make mozzarella-style curd, heat it in hot water or whey until it stretches, pull it into ropes, and chill them quickly in cold water. Everything depends on the stretch. If the curd's acidity is right, the proteins line up into long fibers when you work them hot, and those fibers are what peel off in strings. If the acidity is off, you get either a crumbly mess or a rubbery ball. This is called pasta filata, which means spun paste, and it's the same method behind fresh mozzarella and provolone.
Start with the right curd
Make a mozzarella curd using whole milk, an acid source or starter, and rennet. Some home recipes use citric acid for speed. Others use thermophilic culture and a longer ripening. Either can work, but the curd needs to reach the right acidity before stretching. Many makers test by dipping a small piece of curd in hot water and seeing if it stretches like taffy.
If it breaks apart, it needs more time to acidify. If it melts into a puddle, it went too far. Use a trusted recipe and test small pieces first.
Heat and stretch
Cut the drained curd into small pieces and place them in a heat-safe bowl. Pour over hot water or hot whey, often in the range of 170 to 180°F. Wear heavy gloves, because that water can burn. Fold and stretch the curd with a spoon, then your hands, until it turns smooth, shiny and elastic.
Salt it while working, either in the water or by sprinkling. If the curd cools and goes stiff, return it to the hot water for a moment.
Shape the ropes
When the curd stretches cleanly without tearing, pull it into a long rope about the thickness of your finger or a bit more. Cut into lengths and drop each straight into ice water to set the shape. A fast chill keeps the surface firm and keeps the fibers aligned.
For thicker, dense string cheese, fold and pull a few times before shaping. For a lower-moisture style, drain and rest the pieces in the fridge for a day or two, since moisture changes the texture.
Fixing common problems
- Crumbles or won't stretch: the curd is under-acidified or too cold.
- Greasy, loose and runny: too much heat or too much working.
- Tough and rubbery: overworked or stretched when too acidic.
- Bland: under-salted.
Change one thing at a time. A thermometer and a notebook are cheap, and a lost pot of milk isn't.
Moisture and aging your string cheese
Fresh stretched string cheese has high moisture and a short shelf life. Many commercial products are lower in moisture, which is why they last longer and peel into neat strings. If you want a similar result, let the formed sticks drain and rest, uncovered or loosely covered, in the refrigerator for a day or two, then wrap them.
You can also brine the ropes briefly for flavor and a firmer surface, using a strong salt solution for a short time. Taste, then adjust next time.
Smoking string cheese is popular, using the same cold smoke approach as other cheese. Keep the sticks cold and handle them with clean hands. Whatever you do, don't skip refrigeration, since a moist stretched curd is a friendly place for spoilage bacteria.
Safety while stretching
Hot water and hot whey cause burns. Wear heat-resistant gloves, keep children and pets out of the work area, and don't rush. Use a clean thermometer to check water temperature. Keep your hands and tools sanitized, since the curd goes straight to a ready-to-eat product.
Storage, safety and further help
String cheese is a ready-to-eat dairy product. Keep it cold, packed in clean wrap or a light brine, and eat it within the time your safe handling plan allows. For sale, you'll need appropriate licensing and labeling. Start with your state dairy regulator and the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.
The University of Wisconsin farm resources and Penn State Extension are places to find cheesemaking help. For dairy marketing context, see Dairy Markets and the U.S. Dairy site.
Kids will happily test every batch you make. That's free quality control, though not the most reliable kind.