How do I plan a manure storage expansion?

Size it for the next herd, not the last

ROCHESTER, Minnesota — The best way to plan a manure storage expansion is to start from the days of storage you actually need, size for the herd and wash water you expect, get a qualified engineer involved early, and line up permits and financing before you pour anything. Storage that's a little too big is an annoyance; storage that's too small is a standing problem.

Planning costs a fraction of building, and mistakes in concrete are expensive to reverse.

Define what the storage has to do

List your goals. How many days of storage do you need to avoid spreading in bad weather or frozen conditions? Your nutrient management plan, permit or state rules may set a minimum. What herd size are you planning for over the life of the structure? What goes in: manure, bedding, parlor wash water, runoff and rainfall?

Ask your engineer or NRCS contact how storage volume is figured, including a freeboard allowance and design storm. Don't guess at those. The NRCS has conservation practice standards for waste storage that many states and programs follow, and your state extension site, such as University of Minnesota Extension and farm management resources, has related planning material.

Pick the type and the site

Options include earthen basins or lagoons, concrete or steel tanks, below-barn pits and stacking pads for solids. The right choice depends on your manure type, soils, water table, space and budget.

Site selection matters. Check soil survey information through the Web Soil Survey, look at depth to groundwater and bedrock, distance to wells, streams and neighbors, floodplains, slopes and truck access. Some sites that look convenient are poor choices for liquid storage. Get soil borings if your engineer recommends them.

Bring in an engineer and check the rules

Hire a qualified engineer or technical service provider to design the structure. Design involves liners or concrete specs, inlet and outlet details, safety features and construction inspection. Don't rely on a neighbor's plan for a different soil.

Before design is final, talk with your state environmental or agriculture agency and your county. Ask what permits, setbacks, plan updates and construction standards apply, and how long approvals take. If you're near a permit threshold, ask how expansion affects your status. Rules differ widely; get the answers from the agency itself.

Plan the money and the schedule

Get written bids and compare what's included, such as excavation, liner, concrete, piping, pumps, covers and fencing. Add engineering, permitting, inspection and contingency. Ask about financing and cost-share early, because many programs require approval before work starts. See farmers.gov loans, your local FSA office and NRCS, and your regular lender.

Schedule construction when ground conditions help, and make sure you can handle manure during construction. That often means an interim hauling plan. Where will it go while the pit is under repair? Answer that before the excavator arrives.

Build safety and operation into the design

Include safe access, railings, covers or fencing, ventilation for enclosed spaces, agitation points and a plan for removing solids. Think about how you'll monitor levels and maintain pumps. CDC NIOSH agriculture covers gas and confined-space hazards.

After construction, keep as-built drawings, inspection records and operating instructions. Update your nutrient management plan and spill response plan to include the new storage. A good storage design is one you can run safely every spring and fall for many years without having to think about it.

Take a little time to think about growth and change. If you might add cows, change bedding, install a separator or start taking in outside material, tell your engineer now so the design allows for it. Ask what it would cost to add capacity later versus building a bit larger today, and what the permit would require for either path. Think about how you'll empty it too: where the agitator and pump go, how trucks reach it and where solids will settle. Visit a few farms with similar storage and ask what they'd change. Most will have a list. Bring that list back to your engineer, and write down your own priorities before the first bid arrives. A storage that fits next decade's herd is less trouble than one that fit the herd you used to have.