What is the best way to sample cheese?

Trier, tasting, and plugging the hole

BRATTLEBORO, Vermont — The best way to sample a wheel of cheese before it's cut is with a cheese trier, a curved metal tool that pulls out a narrow plug from the wheel's rind to its center, and then you taste the plug and put the rind end back to seal the hole. For cheese already cut, you simply taste a small piece at room temperature, in good order, with a clean palate. Sampling is how you decide whether a cheese is ready, how it's changing and what to expect from the rest of the batch. Done with care, it leaves the wheel nearly as good as before.

Use a trier correctly

Wipe the trier with a food-safe sanitizer before each wheel. Push it in at a slight angle near the edge, rotate it a half turn, and pull out the plug. Take it from a spot where the plug won't ruin presentation. Don't sample from the same place twice.

Taste the center and the section near the rind, since flavor and texture can differ. Then press the rind end of the plug back into the hole, smooth the surface and, for natural rinds, dab it with brine or a bit of wax for waxed wheels.

Let the cheese warm up

Cold dulls flavor. Take a sample piece out of the fridge about half an hour before tasting if the cheese is firm. Soft cheeses need less warming. Taste in a quiet, clean room with good light, and avoid strong smells like coffee or perfume.

Use plain water or unsalted crackers between samples to reset your palate.

What to look and taste for

Work through the senses in order.

  1. Look: color, openings, cracks, uniform paste.
  2. Smell: milky, nutty, earthy or sharp, and any off odors like ammonia or sourness that doesn't fit the style.
  3. Feel: rub a bit between your fingers. Is it crumbly, smooth, waxy or gummy?
  4. Taste: salt, acid, sweetness, bitterness and finish.

Take notes right away. Memory is a poor tool after the fourth wedge.

Sample for decisions

Taste at set points, such as every few weeks, so you see how flavor changes. Sample across a batch, not only your favorite wheel. If you plan to sell, try a few wheels from each make date, since small differences in acidity or salt can change flavor.

Keep a log with the date, cheese, room conditions and what you tasted. It becomes your aging playbook.

Sampling at events and markets

Offering samples sells cheese, but it also brings risk. Many states have rules on how samples must be cut, covered and handled. Use toothpicks or small cups, keep cheese on ice or in a cooler, and wear gloves. Keep samples small and replace the plate regularly.

Put out a label for each sample showing the cheese name and any allergen, including milk and nuts if you serve crackers. Tell people if a cheese is made from raw milk.

If a customer asks about pregnancy or illness and certain cheeses, don't give medical advice. Say what the cheese is and how it was made, and suggest they ask their doctor. That's honest and keeps you out of trouble.

Sampling for yourself versus for customers

Your own samples are about data. Customer samples are about sales and safety. Keep them separate. A plug removed for your own testing should come from a wheel you don't plan to sell, or be sealed up carefully if you do. Don't hand customers plugs you've already tasted from.

Food safety and learning more

Keep samples clean. Don't double-dip, and don't return a bitten piece to the wheel. At farmers markets or events, check your state's sampling rules, since some require specific handling. Start with your state dairy regulator and the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.

For tasting and technical resources, see Penn State Extension, the University of Wisconsin farm resources and Cornell Small Farms.

Testing your own cheese is the one job where eating on the clock is justified.