What's the best way to stretch forage supplies?

Cut shrink, feed by group, fill gaps

SIOUX CITY, Iowa — The cheapest way to stretch forage is to stop losing it. Silage shrink, spoiled bale ends, bunk leftovers and trampled hay can add up to a large share of what you grew, and that waste is feed you already paid for. After that comes feeding by group, swapping part of the forage with other fiber sources and trimming animals that aren't earning their keep.

This article is about the math and the mechanics, not about weather. Whatever caused the shortage, the same steps apply.

Measure first, then cut

Before changing anything, put numbers on the supply. Estimate tons of dry matter in each silage structure and each hay lot, and divide by daily use. Then check how much you're really feeding. Weigh a few loads from the mixer and compare to what the ration says. Mixers drift, scales go off, and loaders pile on an extra bucket when nobody's watching.

You can't manage what you haven't measured. The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker library has budgeting tools and information sheets that help with this kind of tallying.

Trim the leaks

Common leaks on dairy farms include:

Fixes are mostly boring. Cut silage faces clean and keep them tight, remove enough from the face each day to stay ahead of spoilage, and cover storage well. Store hay off the ground and under cover when you can. Feed bales in rings or feeders for dry stock. Push up feed often. For a farm that loses even a modest fraction of its feed to shrink, cutting that loss in half is like finding a free field.

Extension sources such as Penn State Extension and the Kansas State research and extension site publish storage and feeding loss studies that explain where losses come from.

Feed by group and match feed to need

Dry cows, bred heifers and late-lactation animals don't need your best forage. Move poorer forage to those groups and balance with minerals, then save the best for fresh and high-producing cows. Check that you aren't overfeeding energy to groups that don't need it, since extra feed is just money in manure.

Groups should be sorted by stage and size where you can, because a single mixed pen forces you to feed to the neediest animal. If you only have two pens, put the thin cows and heifers in a pen with a different ration.

Replace some forage with other fiber

Part of the forage can often be replaced with other fibrous feeds: soy hulls, beet pulp, cottonseed, wheat midds and similar byproducts, depending on region and price. Straw and corn stalks can fill the gap in dry cow and heifer rations. Always change the ration gradually, and keep effective fiber in the milking ration so rumen health holds up.

Prices swing, so check regional reports from AMS Market News and compare cost per pound of dry matter, not cost per ton as delivered. A cheap wet byproduct can be an expensive feed once you account for water.

Talk to your nutritionist before substituting anything. A ration that looks cheaper on paper can cost milk if fiber, protein or fat is out of balance.

Shrink the herd to fit the feed

Sometimes the honest answer is fewer animals. Open cows, cows with chronic health problems and heifers that are too many for your herd all eat feed. Review the culling list with your vet and nutritionist. Selling a low-value animal early often beats feeding her through a shortage and selling her anyway.

Also watch your replacement heifer inventory. Raising more heifers than you need is a quiet feed drain, and it's one of the few places to cut without touching milk production.

Check your numbers against reality every couple of weeks. Re-measure the silage face, recount bales and compare the days of feed you predicted with what's left. If cows are eating faster than the plan, find out why now, whether it's a ration change, a mixer error or more animals than you counted. Catching a small gap early gives you time to buy or cull on your terms.

Finally, write the plan down: days of feed on hand, planned changes, who's responsible for each and what triggers the next step. A plan on a clipboard beats a plan in your head at five in the morning.