What is the best way to taste test cheese?
Look, smell, feel, taste, wait
BURLINGTON, Vermont — The best way to taste cheese is slowly and in a set order: look at it, smell it, feel it, taste it, then notice what lingers. Do it at the right temperature, in a quiet spot, with plain water and a bland cracker to reset your palate. Taste several cheeses side by side if you can, mild first and strong last. That's it. The rest is practice and good notes.
Set up the tasting
Take cheese out of the cooler about an hour before tasting. Cold cheese is quiet cheese, because fats are stiff and aromas hide. Cut samples from the same part of the wheel when possible, since the rind and the center can taste very different. Use clean knives and plain plates, and avoid strong perfume, coffee or mints beforehand. Give each sample a code, not a name, if you want honest opinions. Pour room-temperature water, and offer plain crackers or unsalted bread. Light matters too: look at the cheese in daylight or neutral lighting so you can judge color accurately.
Look and smell
Check the rind and surface first: is it clean, moldy as intended, cracked, slimy, greasy? Look at the paste for color, eyes (holes), cracks or uneven texture. Then smell: break a piece and sniff from close. Describe what you get in plain words: milky, nutty, grassy, barnyard, sour, buttery, sharp, yeasty. Off smells like ammonia, strong mustiness not typical of the style, or rancid notes may mean a defect or over-ripening, though some styles lean strong by design.
Texture and taste
Press the cheese with your thumb, then rub a bit between your fingers. Is it firm, springy, crumbly, pasty or fudgy? Then take a small piece and let it warm in your mouth. Chew slowly, pressing it against the roof of your mouth. Note salt, sweetness, acidity and bitterness. Note texture: grainy, smooth, dry or sticky. Pay attention to flavor development: what you taste first, what comes in the middle, what remains at the end. Then notice the finish. Does it fade quickly or linger? A pleasant, clean finish usually means good balance.
Keep notes you can use
Use a simple score sheet with the same categories every time: appearance, aroma, texture, flavor, finish, and overall. Add a space for comments and for defects like gas holes, bitterness or sourness. A few lines are enough. If you make cheese, record the batch number, age and make notes so you can trace a good result back to the process. Taste the same cheese at different ages to see how it develops. Extension programs such as Wisconsin's Center for Dairy Research partners and Penn State Extension offer cheesemaking and evaluation resources, and the US Dairy site has general dairy information. For help marketing what you make, AgMRC has value-added guidance.
Common mistakes
- Tasting too cold.
- Tasting too many strong cheeses in a row.
- Talking about the cheese before everyone has written their notes.
- Judging a cheese against a style it was never meant to be.
- Skipping water between samples.
Taste with an open mind, and trust your notes more than your mood. If you plan to sell the cheese, ask a few customers who don't know you well. Friends and family will say it's wonderful, which is lovely but not very useful. Strangers are better, and they tell you about the salt.