What is the coverage level decision?
Picking your margin floor
TULARE, California — The coverage level decision is the choice you make when you enroll in Dairy Margin Coverage: the margin number, in dollars per hundredweight, below which the program starts paying you. Pick a low level and you pay a small premium but the program rarely pays. Pick a high level and you pay more, and the program pays more often. It's the single biggest lever you have inside the program, and it's worth treating as a financial decision, not a coin flip.
The available levels, and the premium for each, are set by law and USDA, and they can change, so check with FSA before you plan around any number.
What the level means
Your coverage level is a margin floor. Each month, FSA calculates a national margin from the national all-milk price and a feed cost formula. If that margin is below your chosen level, you get a payment based on the difference and on the amount of production you've covered. If the margin is at or above your level, you get nothing that month. So the decision is about how much of the bad stretch you want the program to catch. The Farm Service Agency posts the options, the premium schedule and how payments are calculated.
What it costs
Premiums rise with the coverage level, and they may differ depending on how much production you cover. There may also be an administrative fee. Because of that, higher coverage isn't automatically better. The cost of the extra coverage has to be weighed against how often you think the margin will fall into the range it protects. Ask your county FSA office for the current premium table in writing, and also ask whether any discounts apply for multi-year commitments or for certain producers. Terms vary over time.
How to anchor the decision to your farm
Start with your own numbers, not the national ones. What does it cost you to produce a hundredweight of milk, including feed, labor, interest and family living? What margin do you need to cover debt payments? Your lender can help. Then compare your cost situation with how the national margin has moved in the past. The Center for Farm Financial Management and farmdoc daily publish decision tools and analysis that help you test different levels against past margins. The University of Wisconsin farm management site is another solid place to look.
Think about the cost of a bad year
The point of the program is to protect against a stretch bad enough to threaten the farm. Ask yourself:
- How many months of tight margins could my cash reserve handle?
- Which loan payments are due in a stretch like that?
- Would my lender extend operating credit, and on what terms?
- Do I have other tools in place, such as price protection through my buyer or insurance?
If the honest answer is that a couple of bad months would put you in trouble, a higher level may be worth the premium. If you're well capitalized, a lower level may fit.
How the decision interacts with other tools
Dairy revenue insurance, forward contracts and your co-op's programs all affect how much you need from DMC. The Risk Management Agency can point you to a licensed agent who can walk you through insurance. Layering tools can cover different risks, but it also adds cost, so look at the total cost of protection across everything you buy.
A simple way to decide
- Write down your break-even margin.
- Get the current premium table from FSA.
- Compare each level's cost to what it would have paid in past years, using published data.
- Talk to your lender.
- Choose, sign and save the paperwork.
Perfect timing isn't possible. Nobody knows what feed will cost next summer, including the people who sell it.