Mesophilic versus thermophilic cultures

Temperature decides which one you use

LOGAN, Utah — The difference is the temperature each group of bacteria prefers. Mesophilic cultures grow best at moderate temperatures and are used for cheeses made at or near room-to-body temperature, like cheddar, gouda, and chevre. Thermophilic cultures grow best at higher temperatures and are used for cheeses that get cooked, like mozzarella, parmesan style cheeses, and Swiss types. Pick the wrong one and your culture either sits idle or dies in the heat.

What the names mean

"Meso" means middle and "thermo" means heat. Mesophilic bacteria thrive in a moderate range, roughly from the seventies into the low nineties in Fahrenheit. Thermophilic bacteria tolerate and prefer warmer conditions, often working best somewhere around body temperature up into the low or mid hundred-and-teens, depending on the strain. Exact ranges vary by culture, so use the supplier's data sheet.

What each one does in the vat

Both types turn lactose into lactic acid. What differs is the speed, the temperature window, and often the flavor. Mesophilic cultures acidify steadily at make temperatures and give mild, buttery, or lactic flavors. Some mesophilic blends also produce carbon dioxide and flavor compounds, giving the small eyes and aroma of certain styles.

Thermophilic cultures acidify quickly at higher temperatures. Their quick acid production fits cheeses that are cooked in the vat, and some make a sweeter, nutty profile in aged hard cheese.

Matching culture to cheese

Check your recipe's make temperature. If you stir curd at 90 degrees Fahrenheit and keep it there, use a mesophilic type. If you heat curd well into the hundreds, use a thermophilic type.

What happens if you mix them up

Add a thermophilic culture to cool milk and it will acidify slowly or not at all, giving a sweet, underdeveloped cheese that won't expel whey. Add a mesophilic culture before a high-heat cook and the heat kills the bacteria, leaving curd with too little acid and poor texture.

If you're not sure, read the culture packet. It lists the temperature ranges, the cheeses it suits, and the recommended dose.

Practical tips

  1. Write the culture name on the packet and in your notebook.
  2. Keep cultures frozen or as the supplier directs.
  3. Use the recommended dose per gallon rather than guessing.
  4. Warm milk to the culture's working temperature before adding it, then give it time to rehydrate on the surface before stirring in.
  5. Check acid development with a pH meter or by following the recipe's timing.

Reading a data sheet

Every culture supplier lists a working temperature range, a recommended dose, and suggested cheeses. Treat that sheet as the rulebook. It will also say whether the culture produces gas, flavor compounds, or only acid, which matters if you don't want eyes in a cheddar. If two cultures look similar, choose the one whose range matches your make temperature.

When a recipe uses both

Some traditional cheeses combine culture types so acid develops in stages. A blend might use a mesophilic culture for early flavor and a thermophilic one that wakes up during the cook. If your recipe lists two cultures, add them as directed, in the order and at the temperatures given. Don't merge them into one scoop. Also remember that cooking a vat past a mesophilic culture's limit stops its work entirely, so any acid you still need must come from the thermophilic partner.

A quick decision rule

Look at the hottest step in your recipe. If the curd never goes much above the low hundreds in Fahrenheit and stays warm rather than hot, reach for a mesophilic culture. If the recipe cooks curd well above that or stretches it in hot water, reach for a thermophilic one. When a recipe doesn't say, ask the culture supplier, who will usually answer in a sentence.

Where to learn more

eXtension, Cornell small farms, and the University of Wisconsin farm extension site offer dairy processing and cheese-related material. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service covers food safety, and your state agriculture department can tell you what applies if you sell.

Think of it as a thermostat choice for bacteria. Mesophilic for mild, thermophilic for hot, and neither one is happy when you misread the recipe.