What is the milk price formula?
Product prices in, milk prices out
DES MOINES, Iowa — The milk price formula takes wholesale prices for cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and dry whey, subtracts a make allowance for the cost of manufacturing each, and converts what's left into values for butterfat, protein and other solids that then become class prices. In plain terms, the formula works backward from what the dairy products sell for. If a pound of cheese is worth more, the milk that goes into it is worth more, after a standard amount comes off for the cost of making it.
I'll give the structure, not any current numbers, since the factors are reviewed and can change. Read the current rule before you do any math.
Start with the product price survey
Each week, USDA's National Agricultural Statistics Service collects price and volume information from manufacturers on cheddar cheese, butter, nonfat dry milk and dry whey sold in the previous week. The results are reported publicly. Those weekly survey prices are averaged across the month for the monthly price calculations. The NASS site has the reports and the AMS has the dairy market news that explains them.
Because the survey drives everything, a change in how it is conducted, or in how much product is sold on spot versus contract, can move the pricing outcome. Watch the survey notes along with the numbers.
Subtract make allowances and apply yields
The formula assumes it costs a certain amount to turn milk into each product, called a make allowance, and that a given amount of milk yields a certain amount of each product, called a yield factor. Those factors are set in the federal order rules and can be changed through the order amendment process. They're the reason there's debate in the industry, because a higher make allowance lowers the farm milk price for a given product price and a lower one raises it.
You can find the current factors in the federal order regulations and in the Federal Register notices announcing changes. If you read an article that claims the formula is unfair, check which factors it uses.
From components to class prices
The formula produces a price for butterfat, one for protein and one for other solids. Class III combines protein and butterfat and other solids from the cheese and whey prices, and Class IV uses butter and nonfat dry milk. Class II and Class I use pieces of these. Class I includes an advanced pricing step and a location adjustment, which matter for bottlers and the farms that supply them.
Class prices are applied to the pounds of each component used. The class value of all milk in the order goes into the pool, and the order pays out an average to each farm.
What the formula does not include
The formula doesn't know your hauling bill, your co-op's marketing deduction or your premium for low cell count. It also doesn't know the price of your feed. Those items determine your actual margin. It also isn't a promise about what processors will pay in the open market, since they can pay more than the minimum. A formula that keeps minimum prices moving with product prices does not guarantee a profit to any farm.
For analysis of how the formula performs against costs, university economists publish regularly. Farmdoc daily and the Iowa State agricultural decision maker pages are two places to read dairy margin discussions.
Why the formula draws arguments
Farmers, co-ops and processors don't always agree on the make allowances or yield factors, because they decide how much of each product dollar gets credited back to the milk. Processors argue that plant costs have risen and the allowance should reflect that, while farm groups point out that a higher allowance cuts what producers see. Neither side is lying, they're counting different costs. When a hearing is announced, the proposals and testimony are public, so you can read both sides before you decide where you stand or how to vote through your cooperative.
How to use the formula yourself
- Pull the latest announced prices for butterfat, protein and other solids.
- Multiply by the pounds of each component in your milk test.
- Add your premiums and subtract your deductions.
- Compare the result to your statement, and ask your handler about the difference.
- Track the weekly product prices to see where the next month may be heading.
A farm that builds a small spreadsheet with this setup can see a price change coming before the check arrives. It will not tell you exactly what next month holds, but it will make the announcement day less of a surprise.