What should I ask a feed consultant?
Pay, proof and who owns the data
LUBBOCK, Texas — Ask a feed consultant how they're paid, what they've done on farms like yours, how they'll measure results and who owns the data. Those four questions sort out most of the good ones from the rest. The ration advice may be sound either way, but the way the arrangement is built changes what you'll be steered toward, and you're entitled to know that before you sign anything.
Hiring a consultant is a business decision, so treat it like hiring a mechanic or an accountant. References, scope and payment terms belong in the conversation.
How are you paid?
Consultants are paid in different ways. Some charge a flat fee or hourly rate, some are employed by a feed company and some work on commission tied to product sales. None of these is automatically wrong. But each creates a different incentive. A consultant paid by the feed they sell has a reason to recommend purchased feed. An independent one has a reason to keep you as a client, which usually means producing results.
Ask plainly. "If I buy feed from someone else, does anything change? Do you earn money from products you recommend?" A good consultant will answer without sweating. Ask for the fee structure in writing, including what's covered: farm visits, ration updates, forage testing, reports, phone support and herd reviews.
What's your training and track record?
Credentials vary. Ask about education, certifications and years working with herds like yours in size, breed and system. Certified Crop Advisers, for instance, can help on the crop side, and you can verify them through the Certified Crop Adviser program. For animal nutrition, ask what animal science training and professional certifications they hold, and verify them with the issuing body.
Then ask for references. Talk to two or three farms of similar type, and ask what happened when something went wrong. Everyone has a good year. A consultant's value shows up in a bad one.
How will you work on my farm?
Find out how often the consultant will visit, what they do on a visit, and what they'll bring. A solid visit includes looking at cows and pens, checking bunks and refusals, reviewing mixer loads, scoring body condition and manure, and reviewing forage tests. A weak visit is a quick look at a printout.
Ask about forage sampling. Who takes the samples, which lab, how often, and how results change the ration? Ask how the consultant handles a sudden problem, like a drop in milk or a spike in health events, and how fast they respond.
Also ask who talks to the vet. Nutrition and herd health overlap, and the best results come when the consultant and vet talk to each other. The American Association of Bovine Practitioners can help you find vets who work with nutritionists on transition and fresh cow programs.
How will we measure results?
Agree on measures before work starts. These could include milk yield, components, dry matter intake, feed cost per cow, income over feed cost, body condition, reproduction and fresh cow health. Set a review schedule, and decide what happens if targets aren't met.
Pull in neutral numbers where you can. The University of Minnesota's Center for Farm Financial Management and the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker publish tools for tracking feed costs and margins. If you can't tell whether the program is working, neither can the consultant.
Who owns the data, and what's in writing?
Ask who owns formulations, feed analyses, herd records and reports. Ask whether you can have copies, and whether you can take them to a new consultant. Ask what's confidential, and whether your data is used or sold in any way.
Get the agreement in writing: scope, fees, term, how to end it and what you receive. Read it. If you don't understand a clause, ask.
- How are you paid, and do you earn money from products you recommend?
- What's your training, and can I verify it?
- Can I talk to farms like mine?
- What does a typical visit include?
- What results will we track, and how often will we review?
- Who owns the data and formulas?
- How do I end the arrangement?
Pick the consultant who answers all seven without getting defensive. The one who gets prickly at question one has told you what you needed to know.