What should I ask about dairy sustainability?
Questions that get past the buzzwords
AMES, Iowa — When you ask a dairy about sustainability, the best questions are specific and tied to things the farm can measure or show you. "Are you sustainable?" gets a yes every time. "What happens to the manure, and how do you decide when to spread it?" gets an actual answer. Sustainability on a dairy covers land, water, air, animals, people and money, and a good farm can talk about all of them without a brochure.
Ask about manure and nutrients
Manure is the biggest sustainability question on most dairies, since it can be a valuable fertilizer or a water-quality problem depending on how it's handled. Ask how the farm stores manure, how it decides application rates and timing, and whether it follows a nutrient management plan. Ask how it keeps manure out of streams and ditches. NRCS works with farmers on nutrient management and conservation planning, and the Nutrient Stewardship site explains the basic principles of using nutrients carefully.
A farm that shows you a storage structure, a soil test and a spreading plan is giving you real information.
Ask about soil and feed
Cows eat what the land grows, so soil health is part of dairy sustainability. Ask what crops the farm grows for feed, whether it uses cover crops or reduced tillage, and how much feed it buys versus raises. Ask how the farm manages pasture if the cows graze. The Soil Health Institute and SARE's cover crop resources cover these practices in plain language.
Buying feed isn't a failing. Many good farms do. Ask where it comes from and how the farm balances rations to avoid waste.
Ask about animals and people
Sustainability includes how animals and workers are treated. Ask about calf care, hoof health, veterinary relationships and how the farm handles sick animals. Ask whether it participates in a recognized animal care program. The U.S. Dairy site is a place to look for industry programs on animal care and environmental goals. Ask about employee training, safety and turnover, since a farm that keeps good workers usually treats animals better too.
The OSHA agriculture page is a useful reference for worker safety on farms.
Ask about energy, water and waste
Ask how the farm uses water in the parlor and for cooling, and whether it reuses any of it. Ask about energy: lighting, cooling, ventilation, and whether the farm captures or produces any of its own. Ask what happens to plastic wrap, milk filters and other waste. Be skeptical of one big feature, like a solar array, standing in for the whole picture. A farm can have panels on the roof and still have a manure problem.
Ask about money
A farm that can't pay its bills isn't sustainable, no matter how green its practices look. Ask how the farm plans to be in business in ten or twenty years, and whether the next generation is involved. That isn't nosy. It's the same question you'd ask any business you were counting on.
Read claims carefully
Terms like "natural," "eco-friendly" and "green" have no single legal meaning on a dairy label. "Organic" does, and the AMS organic standards set it out. When a farm makes a claim, ask what practice stands behind it and whether a third party checks it.
Use outside sources to check the answers
After you talk to the farm, compare what you heard with independent information. Your county extension office can tell you what practices are common for farms in your area and how they work. Extension and SARE publish practical material on manure, soil, grazing and energy. If a farm mentions a program or certification, look up the program's own page and see what it requires. You're not trying to catch anyone out. You're trying to learn what the words mean, since the same word can describe very different practices from one farm to the next. A farmer who welcomes follow-up questions is usually one who has nothing to hide.
The best answer to a sustainability question is often "here, let me show you." The second best is an honest "we're working on that."