Which advisors help with milk marketing?

Who to call, and what each one can do

STILLWATER, Oklahoma — Several kinds of advisors help with milk marketing, and each sees a different part of the picture. Your co-op or processor field rep knows how your milk is priced and sold. Extension educators and university economists explain markets and run workshops. Crop insurance agents sell and explain Dairy Revenue Protection. FSA staff handle Dairy Margin Coverage. Lenders and farm business consultants look at your margins and cash flow. Licensed brokers handle futures and options. You rarely need all of them, but knowing what each one does keeps you from asking a banker to explain a pay price formula.

Your co-op or processor

Start here, because they set your price. A field representative can explain your pay price formula, premiums, deductions, hauling charges, and contract terms. Ask how component pricing works, what quality premiums apply, and what marketing options are available, such as forward pricing programs. A co-op's market analysts often publish commentary and can answer questions on outlook. Remember that they have their own interests, so supplement what you hear with independent sources.

Extension and university economists

Extension educators are paid to help farmers, not to sell anything. They run workshops on dairy markets, cost of production, and risk management. Find yours through extension.org or your state's land-grant university. Several universities publish excellent resources, including farmdoc daily, the Iowa State ag decision maker, the University of Wisconsin farms site, and the Center for Farm Financial Management. Many offer farm business analysis programs where an educator helps you benchmark your numbers.

Crop insurance agents and FSA

Dairy Revenue Protection is sold through crop insurance agents, who are licensed and work with companies overseen by the Risk Management Agency. Ask an agent to show you quotes at several coverage levels and explain the cost. Dairy Margin Coverage is handled through county offices of the Farm Service Agency, where staff help you sign up and explain coverage choices. Get both views before choosing. Neither will tell you the future price, but both can tell you what each product would have done in past scenarios.

Lenders and farm business advisors

Your lender cares about repayment, so they'll want to see your risk plan. Ask what they'd like to see for protection levels and what ratios matter to them. Independent farm business consultants and certified advisors can build budgets and test scenarios. If you hire one, ask about credentials, experience with dairy, how they're paid, and whether they sell products. Advisors paid by commission may favor products that pay them. That's not necessarily wrong, but you should know.

Brokers and market advisory services

If you want to use futures or options, you'll need a licensed commodity broker, and you should understand margin calls before you start. Some firms sell market advisory services with recommendations. Check how long they've operated, how they disclose performance, and what they charge. Be skeptical of anyone promising to beat the market. Ask for references from other dairy farmers and keep your own records of what advice cost versus what it delivered.

Questions to ask any advisor

  1. How are you paid, and by whom?
  2. What dairy experience do you have?
  3. What would you do in a bad price year?
  4. Can I see how your advice has worked for other producers?
  5. What do you need from me?

An advisor should be able to answer plainly. Then compare two before choosing. Good advice tends to be boring and specific; flashy advice tends to be neither.