Which buffer strips protect water?
Grass, trees and mixed strips each help
BLOOMINGTON, Illinois — Several kinds of buffer strips protect water: grass filter strips, riparian forest buffers, grassed waterways, field borders and multi-species buffers that combine trees, shrubs and grass. Which protects best depends on the problem. Grass is strong at slowing runoff and trapping sediment. Trees and shrubs stabilize banks, shade water and take up nutrients. Width, plant density and upkeep matter as much as the plant type, and a well-kept grass strip will beat a neglected tree planting every time. Here's how each kind works and where it fits.
Grass filter strips
Dense, permanent grass slows overland flow, which lets sediment settle and gives water time to soak in. They work best when runoff arrives as a thin sheet, not as a concentrated stream. If water gathers into a gully, it will shoot straight through the strip. Fix that with grading or a grassed waterway first. Grass strips need mowing or harvest at suitable times and protection from spray drift and heavy traffic. Watch for sediment building up at the upslope edge, which can create a small berm and push water sideways. NRCS conservation practice standards describe design details, and your local office can help plan one.
Riparian forest buffers
Trees and shrubs along a stream hold the bank with deep roots, shade the water to keep it cooler, and take up nutrients in the root zone. They also provide wildlife habitat. They take years to establish and need protection from deer, weeds and livestock while young. A multi-zone design with trees nearest the stream and grass farther out is common. Plant choice should suit your soils and wetness, so ask before ordering seedlings. Local conservation districts, listed through the National Association of Conservation Districts, often help with plant choices, planting dates and sources of seedlings.
Grassed waterways and field borders
A grassed waterway carries concentrated runoff down a draw without cutting a gully. A field border is a strip of perennial cover at the field edge. Neither replaces a streamside buffer, but both reduce erosion upslope and help buffers function. Keep waterways free of crossings that cut ruts, and don't use them as turnaround space. Check them after storms for rilling and fix problems quickly, since small rills grow fast. Raise implements when crossing, and avoid spraying or tilling right up to the grass so it keeps its density along the edges.
Match the strip to the pollutant
Buffers trap particles such as sediment and attached phosphorus better than dissolved nutrients. Nitrate moving in tile drainage can bypass a buffer completely. Other practices, such as drainage water management or bioreactors, may fit that problem. Ask your planner what is moving off your fields, and in what form. Manure application near a stream still needs setbacks and rate limits regardless of the buffer. The conservation pages at farmers.gov explain USDA programs, and staff at your local USDA service center can tell you what's currently open and what practices qualify.
Maintain what you plant
Buffers fail from neglect more than from design. Control weeds early. Repair erosion channels. Remove sediment buildup that creates a berm and redirects flow. Keep livestock out, or manage access carefully with a hardened crossing. Replace dead trees. Keep a record of what you did and when, which helps if you ever apply for a program or get questions during an inspection. Mark the edges with posts so equipment operators and custom applicators know where the strip begins.
Width is the question everyone asks, and the honest answer is that it depends. Practice standards set minimums that vary by buffer type and by state or program, and wider strips generally trap more. Slope, soil, the amount of runoff and your goals all play a part, so ask your conservation planner what the current standard is for the kind of buffer you're building and what a program would require if you enroll.
Think about money and land, too. A buffer takes ground out of crop production, and that costs something. Some programs offer rental payments or cost-share for certain buffers, and eligibility and rates change, so check with your local USDA service center, which you can find through the service center locator, before you plant. Ask what the contract requires and for how long.
If you're unsure where to begin, ask a conservation planner for a walk of the farm. Free advice is the best kind, and fish don't send thank-you cards, but the water will show the difference.