Which bulls should I select?
Choose for your herd's goals
GREEN BAY, Wisconsin — The bulls you should select are the ones whose proven strengths match your herd's weaknesses and goals, backed by solid data and not just a catchy name in a catalog. A good sire list is short, balanced and based on traits that make you money over a cow's lifetime, not only milk volume. This article walks through how to build a list, what to check and how to avoid the usual traps of picking sires on a single number.
Write down your goals first
Start with a list of what your herd needs. Are fertility and health problems costing you? Are components or milk volume the priority? Do you need better feet and legs, or udders that last? Do calving problems bother you in heifers? Your goals, your milk market and your housing system determine which traits matter most.
Ask your processor or co-op how milk is priced in your area, since that affects whether you lean toward protein, fat or volume.
Use a selection index as a starting point
National and breed organizations publish selection indexes that combine many traits into a single score, weighting them by estimated economic value. An index is a handy filter. Pick one that fits your system, such as a net merit style index or a cheese-oriented index, and use it to narrow the field. Then look inside the index at individual traits so you can steer around weak spots.
Ask your AI company representative how the index is calculated and updated. Indexes change over time as research improves.
Check the health and fertility traits
Many farms now give heavy weight to daughter fertility, calving ease, stillbirth, mastitis resistance, productive life and other health traits. These traits have low heritability, so progress is slow and every point counts. Look for bulls with reliable proofs on these traits and avoid sires with weak scores on traits you struggle with.
If your heifers have calving trouble, look hard at calving ease for first-calf animals. If you use beef semen on part of the herd, plan separate selections for that.
Look at reliability and sample size
A proof based on many daughters, or a genomic evaluation combined with pedigree, is more reliable than one based on little information. Reliability is reported alongside each trait; higher means less likely to change. Young genomic bulls can be a good choice but carry more uncertainty. Spread risk by using several young sires rather than putting all cows on one.
Avoid inbreeding and keep diversity
Use mating tools from your AI company or breed association to avoid close relatives and manage inbreeding. A few popular sires can dominate a breed, and using only those narrows the gene pool. Rotate sires, and use a mix of lines.
Match bulls to your cow groups
Different groups might call for different sires. Heifers might get calving-ease sires, high-merit cows might get sexed semen from top sires, and lower-merit cows might get beef semen. Write it into your breeding plan so inseminators know which straws to use.
Review results
After daughters are born and mature, compare their performance to expectations. Keep records of health, fertility and production by sire. Share the data with your AI representative and advisors so you can adjust.
For more, consult your breed association, your AI company, eXtension, the Dairy Markets site, and the U.S. Dairy site for industry context. farmdoc daily offers economic thinking for planning.
A line to end on: no bull is perfect, and the one with the shiny number in one trait usually has a quiet problem in another. Read the whole page, not just the headline.