Which byproducts suit dairy rations?

Cheap feed that still earns its place

SIOUX FALLS, South Dakota — Many byproduct feeds work well in dairy rations, including distillers grains, soy hulls, corn gluten feed, wheat middlings, beet pulp, brewers grains, whole cottonseed, citrus pulp and bakery waste. None of them is a bargain just because the price per ton looks low. A byproduct pays when it supplies protein, energy or digestible fiber more cheaply than the feeds it replaces, and when you can store and mix it without turning the feed room into a mess.

Sort them by what they do for the cow

Rather than memorizing names, group byproducts by their job:

Digestible fiber feeds can replace part of the corn in a ration, which lowers starch and helps rumen pH. They don't replace forage particle length, though. Cows still need long fiber to chew.

Watch the fat, sulfur and variability

Distillers grains vary by plant and process, and some carry meaningful oil and sulfur. Too much fat reduces fiber digestion and can drop milk fat. High dietary sulfur can cause trouble in the rumen and in the cow, so test your water and your feeds together. Ask your supplier for a current analysis from the actual plant you're buying from, not a book value.

Whole cottonseed is a handy fat and fiber source but has limits. Your nutritionist will keep an eye on total fat in the ration.

Do the math on delivered cost

Compare feeds on a cost-per-unit-of-nutrient basis, not per ton as-fed. A wet byproduct that is mostly water costs more per pound of dry matter than the sticker suggests, and you pay to haul water. Add freight, shrink and storage, then compare with the feed it would replace.

Current prices change constantly. Check recent reports from USDA AMS Market News and local feed dealers, and use the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker feed comparison tools for the arithmetic.

Storage and handling decide the savings

Wet feeds like brewers grains or wet distillers spoil fast, especially in warm weather. Plan for how many days of supply you can use before quality slips. Bunkers, bags and covered piles all need packing and sealing. Dry byproducts are easier but can bridge in bins or draw moisture.

Check that you have the loading and mixing capacity before you sign a contract. A contract for a truckload every week sounds fine until the first rain.

Know the rules and the risks

Check feed labels and any limits on mixing feeds across species. Ruminant protein rules exist for a reason, and some byproducts have restrictions or label guidance. Mycotoxins can concentrate in byproducts when the original grain was contaminated, because the starch removed concentrates what's left. Ask your supplier about mycotoxin testing, particularly after a stressful growing season.

Run any new byproduct past your nutritionist before it goes into the mixer. Introduce it over a week or two, watch intake and manure, and pull it out if the cows tell you it isn't working. Your extension dairy specialist, such as at Penn State Extension, can help check the numbers against your herd.