Which cheeses melt best?
Moisture, age and acid decide it
HASTINGS, Nebraska — The cheeses that melt best are generally young, higher-moisture, moderately acidic ones: mozzarella, young cheddar, Monterey Jack, Colby, fontina, Gruyere, raclette and provolone. They have a protein network that loosens gently when warmed and fat that stays mixed in instead of running off. Cheeses that resist melting are the ones that are very acidic, very dry or made with acid-set curd, like fresh chevre, paneer, halloumi, feta and ricotta. Age matters too, since a very old cheese tends to turn grainy or oily before it turns smooth.
What controls melting
Three things decide how a cheese behaves in heat.
- Moisture: wetter cheese softens and flows more easily.
- Age: as cheese ages, proteins break down and the structure changes, so very old cheese can separate into oil and crumbs.
- Acidity: high acid tightens the protein network, so the cheese holds its shape instead of flowing.
That's why a mild young cheddar melts silkily and an extra-aged one can go greasy.
Good melters for common jobs
- Pizza and baking: low-moisture mozzarella, provolone.
- Grilled sandwiches and burgers: young cheddar, Colby, Monterey Jack, American-style processed cheese.
- Fondue and raclette: Gruyere, Emmental-type, raclette, fontina.
- Mac and cheese: a blend of a good melter with a sharper flavor cheese.
Blends are the usual trick. Combine a smooth melter with a small amount of aged cheese for flavor, and you get the best of both.
Cheeses that don't melt, and why
Some cheeses soften but don't flow. Halloumi and paneer are made to be fried or grilled and hold their shape. Feta and chevre crumble and soften without becoming smooth. Fresh ricotta turns grainy.
That isn't a defect. It's what those cheeses are for. Use them where you want a texture contrast, not a pool of cheese.
Technique tips
Grate the cheese yourself when you can. Pre-shredded cheese often carries anti-caking starch, which can keep it from melting evenly. Let cheese come toward room temperature before you heat it. Use low to moderate heat, and stir gently, since high heat tightens proteins and forces out fat.
Adding a small amount of starch or an emulsifying salt, like sodium citrate, helps even sharp, aged cheeses melt smoothly in sauces.
Choosing cheese for a particular dish
Think about the heat and the time. Pizza needs a cheese that melts quickly, browns lightly and doesn't release a lot of water, which points to low-moisture mozzarella. A grilled cheese sandwich wants a cheese that melts at moderate heat without becoming oily, so young cheddar or Colby works. Baked pasta likes a blend of a melter and a flavor cheese.
For fondue, many cooks pick a cheese with good meltability and some acidity from white wine to keep the mix smooth. Raclette is made to be melted over potatoes, which is why it's soft and elastic when warm.
If you're selling cheese to cooks or restaurants, say how it melts. A short note on the label or sell sheet can save you angry phone calls.
Testing melt yourself
You don't need a lab to compare cheeses. Cut equal cubes of each cheese, put them on a baking sheet and bake at the same temperature for the same time. Compare how far each flows, whether it browns, and how much oil pools. Repeat with cheeses of different ages from the same maker. Notes from a tray of cubes will teach you more than a page of rules, and you get snacks afterward.
Where to learn more
Extension and dairy groups publish information on cheese composition. See Penn State Extension, the University of Wisconsin farm resources and the U.S. Dairy site. If you make cheese to sell and want to know how different styles will perform for customers, the Agricultural Marketing Resource Center can help with value-added planning.
The pizza guy has known all of this for years. He just doesn't charge for it.