Which cheeses suffer from homogenized milk?
Aged and firm cheeses are hit hardest
MANHATTAN, Kansas — The cheeses that suffer most from homogenized milk are the ones that depend on a firm, well-drained curd and long aging: cheddar, gouda, parmesan-style cheeses, Swiss-type cheeses and many other hard or semi-hard wheels. Homogenization makes the curd weaker and wetter, so these cheeses can end up soft, bland or hard to age properly. Fresh and soft cheeses cope much better, and blue cheese sometimes benefits.
How homogenized milk changes the cheese
Smaller fat globules become attached to the protein network, which makes a more tender, moisture-holding gel. The curd is softer, doesn't expel whey as readily and gives a moister cheese with a different texture. For fresh cheese that is usually fine. For a cheese you plan to age, extra moisture can mean slower rind formation, more risk of spoilage organisms and a flavor that develops differently.
Cheeses that struggle
- Cheddar and colby: harder to get the right texture and mat.
- Gouda and edam: can end up soft and slow to firm in the press.
- Parmesan-style and other hard grating cheeses: don't dry out as well.
- Swiss-type cheeses: eye formation and texture can be off.
- Washed-curd and pressed alpine cheeses: may stay too moist.
Cheeses that do fine
Fresh cheeses like ricotta, paneer, queso fresco and cream cheese can use homogenized milk, though results vary. Mozzarella works with homogenized milk, though the stretch may be softer. Bloomy rinds are somewhat tolerant, and some makers prefer the creamier body. Blue cheese is the one style that may actually gain flavor from some homogenization.
How to compensate if it's all you have
- Add calcium chloride, usually per your recipe, to firm the curd.
- Wait a bit longer for a firm set before cutting.
- Cut the curd smaller or cook it a little longer to drive off moisture.
- Be gentle when stirring and ladling.
- Press longer or plan more drying time.
Better milk choices
Look for non-homogenized pasteurized milk, sold as cream-top in many places. Small dairies, co-ops and farm stores often carry it. If you work with your own animals, you already have the best kind. Avoid ultra-pasteurized milk, which has problems even when it isn't homogenized.
Selling cheese
If you sell cheese, labeling and licensing rules apply. Your state agriculture department can tell you what is required. For background, see Penn State Extension, K-State Research and Extension and the USDA Agricultural Marketing Service.
Reading the label
Labels can mislead. Some cartons say homogenized, some say non-homogenized or cream-top, and many say nothing at all. If you can't tell, do a simple test: pour a bit of milk into a clear jar, refrigerate it and see whether a cream layer forms after a day or two. If it does, it isn't homogenized. If you buy milk in bulk from a local source, ask them directly. Keep notes on which brands set well for you. A brand that works great for ricotta may fail for cheddar, and your records will keep you from repeating the same unpleasant surprise.
Practical advice for beginners
If you're just starting out, make fresh cheeses and bloomy rinds with whatever milk you can find, and save the long-aged wheels for when you have good non-homogenized milk. You'll learn the basics of curd handling without wasting a big vat of milk, and you'll also learn how your local milk behaves, which is half of cheesemaking. Also test the milk you plan to use for pH or taste before each batch, since two cartons of the same brand can behave differently from one week to the next. Keep a notebook of which brands set well, which gave soft curd and which were a waste of a morning. Over a few months that list becomes a shopping guide specific to your area.
If your cheddar comes out like a sad sponge, check the milk label before you check the recipe. It's usually the first clue.