Which cheeses suit a beginner cave?

Start with forgiving wheels

WALLA WALLA, Washington — A beginner cave can be as simple as a small refrigerator with a temperature controller. The best cheeses for it are forgiving ones that tolerate small swings in humidity and don't spread mold to everything else. Waxed or natural-rind hard cheeses, such as Gouda-style, Colby, young cheddar and tomme, are good picks. Blue and washed-rind cheeses can take over your space, so leave them for later. Here's how to choose cheeses and set up a simple cave that doesn't turn into a science project.

What a cave needs

Most aged cheeses like roughly 50 to 55 degrees F and humidity in the range of 80 to 90 percent, though recipes vary. A wine fridge or small fridge with an external controller works. Standard refrigerators run too cold and too dry, so the controller is what makes them usable. Add a hygrometer and a lidded tub or container to hold humidity.

Air movement matters, so open the door briefly every day or two. Dead air grows unwanted mold. Place a thermometer and hygrometer where you can read them without opening the door, and check them daily at first. Small units swing quickly when you open them, so don't panic over a reading right after the door closes.

Best starter cheeses

Waxed cheeses like Gouda and Colby are easy because wax seals moisture and limits mold. Young cheddar can be bandaged or waxed. Tomme-style natural-rind cheeses are a bit more work, since they need rind care, but they teach you a lot about moisture and mold.

Look for recipes in the low-to-moderate moisture range. Very soft cheeses are harder to manage and ripen fast, leaving little room for error. A small wheel of a couple of pounds ages faster than a big one, giving you quick feedback.

Cheeses to avoid at first

Blue cheeses spread spores that can contaminate other wheels. Washed-rind cheeses have strong smells and need frequent washing. Bloomy rind cheeses like Brie need specific humidity and short aging windows. These are rewarding but demanding.

If you try one of these, use a separate container or fridge. Cross-contamination is the usual downfall of a shared cave. Keep tools for blue cheese separate from everything else, and wash them thoroughly after use.

Routine care

Check wheels often. Turn them, wipe off unwanted mold with a cloth dipped in light brine or vinegar, and keep surfaces dry. Surface mold of different colors is common, but any slimy rind or off smell deserves attention. Wipe condensation from the fridge walls, since drips onto cheese cause spots.

Keep a log for each cheese, with make date, weight and dated notes. Weighing wheels now and then shows how fast they lose moisture. Taste at intervals, and compare to your notes so you learn what worked.

Safety, sale and resources

Selling aged cheese requires licensing, and raw milk cheeses must meet aging rules. Check with your state dairy regulator and FDA. Home aging for family use still calls for clean milk and tools, and anyone who is pregnant, elderly or has a weak immune system should be careful with raw milk and soft aged cheese.

See Penn State Extension, eXtension, Cornell Small Farms and AgMRC.

A simple weekly routine keeps a cave under control. On cave day, open the door and look at every wheel. Turn each one so moisture doesn't pool underneath. Wipe the shelf with a clean cloth dampened in light brine or a food-safe sanitizer. Note any new mold color, any wheel that feels sticky or any wheel that smells strongly of ammonia, which suggests it's overripe or too wet. Check the temperature log, empty any water that has collected in the humidity tub, and refill it if it has dried out.

If you notice problems, change one variable at a time. Cheeses are slow to answer, so a change on Monday may not show until the following week. Resist the urge to adjust the controller daily, since swinging the settings back and forth usually makes things worse. Ask a local Extension dairy specialist or an experienced maker to look at your cave, and learn from the wheels that don't turn out.

A beginner cave is a refrigerator, a thermometer and some stubbornness.