Which composting methods suit dairies?

Windrows, static piles, bedded packs and more

CORTLAND, New York — Dairies commonly use turned windrows, aerated static piles, in-vessel systems and bedded pack composting, and the best choice depends on herd size, space, equipment, labor, climate and what you want the compost for. Windrows suit farms with a loader or turner and room to spread out. Aerated static piles suit farms that want less turning. Bedded packs, such as compost barns, fold composting into the housing system.

Here's how each works and what to weigh before picking.

Turned windrows

A windrow is a long, narrow pile turned regularly with a loader, a tractor-pulled turner or a self-propelled machine. Turning supplies oxygen, mixes ingredients and manages heat. Windrows are flexible, handle large volumes and don't need much infrastructure beyond a good pad.

The costs are equipment, fuel, labor and space. Windrows need room to turn, and they need an all-weather surface. Frequent turning means time, so check your labor before you commit. Windrows can also be a source of odor when turned, so consider neighbors and wind direction. For farms that sell compost, windrows give consistent product when managed well.

Aerated static piles

In an aerated static pile, air moves through the pile using perforated pipes and fans, rather than turning. Piles are built once with a bulking layer and sometimes covered with a layer of finished compost or a membrane to hold heat and odors. Fans may be timed or controlled by temperature sensors.

The upside is less turning labor and a smaller footprint than windrows. You'll pay for the aeration system, power and controls, and need good mixing at the start because there's no turning to fix mistakes. They can be a good fit for farms with a steady supply of manure and a place for a permanent pad. Ask extension staff and equipment suppliers for experience in your climate, and look at Cornell's small farms program and Extension.org composting materials.

Bedded pack and compost barns

In a compost bedded pack barn, cows live on a deep bed of sawdust or other dry material that gets stirred, usually twice a day, to mix manure into the bedding and keep the surface dry and aerobic. The heat from composting helps dry the pack. Cows rest on soft, dry bedding, and the barn produces compost as a byproduct.

These barns demand good management: regular tilling, enough space per cow, ventilation and a steady supply of dry bedding. Poorly managed packs can get wet, which hurts cow comfort and udder health. Talk with your veterinarian, nutritionist and extension dairy specialist about whether the system fits your herd, and visit working barns before building one. Bedding cost and availability vary a lot by region.

In-vessel and bin systems

In-vessel systems use enclosed bins, drums or tunnels with controlled aeration. They give the most control over temperature and odor, and take little land. They also cost the most to buy and run, and require technical know-how. Some larger dairies use them where odor or space limits make open systems hard, and some manage them as shared or custom services.

Smaller farms sometimes use bin systems with simple turning to compost mortalities or small manure volumes, though check your state's rules for carcass composting, which have specific requirements.

Choose with these questions

  1. How much manure and bedding do I produce, and how steady is it?
  2. How much space and what kind of pad do I have?
  3. What equipment and labor can I count on?
  4. What do neighbors, rules and permits allow?
  5. Is my goal to reduce volume, cut odor, make a product to sell, or improve housing?
  6. What bulking materials can I get, and at what cost?

Costs and returns depend on local markets. Compost sales vary, and many dairies compost primarily to handle manure better, with sales as a bonus. Check your local demand before you count on income, and look at budgeting tools from farmdoc daily or your extension farm management specialist.

Check rules and get help

Composting rules differ by state and size of operation. Some states exempt farm composting of your own manure, while others require registration or limit sales. Ask your state agriculture or environmental agency. Your NRCS service center may be able to help with design and cost-share for covered storage or composting facilities.

Visit farms using the methods you're considering, and ask what they'd do differently. Most will tell you, usually before you finish the question.

The short version

Windrows are flexible, static piles save labor, bedded packs combine housing and composting, and in-vessel systems offer control at higher cost. Pick the one that matches your herd, space and labor, and get local advice before you build anything.