Which crops benefit most from manure?

Heavy feeders, forage and corn lead the list

AMES, Iowa — Crops that take up a lot of nutrients, especially corn, small grains, grass hay, silage crops and many forages, usually benefit most from manure. They have large nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium demands, and many of them are grown in rotations where manure is practical to haul and spread. Still, "benefit most" depends on your soil test, your manure analysis and when you can get on the field.

Manure is a fertilizer and a soil conditioner at once. It adds organic matter, feeds soil life and supplies nutrients. It also brings risks, so match it to the crop and the field.

Corn and other high-demand grain crops

Corn is the classic manure crop. It takes up large amounts of nitrogen, and a good share of that need can be met by manure, particularly when manure is injected or incorporated and applied close to planting or as a sidedress. Corn following a soybean crop or alfalfa often needs less nitrogen, so adjust for those credits.

Wheat and other small grains take manure well too, especially if applied before planting and worked in. Sorghum behaves like corn in many ways.

Test the manure and soil. Your extension office can tell you how much nitrogen is available from different manure types. Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker and NCGA offer production information, and Nutrient Stewardship covers right rate and right timing.

Forage crops and pasture

Grass hay and pastures often respond well to manure because grasses use nitrogen heavily and cut hay removes a lot of nutrients every year. Silage corn and sorghum-sudan crops remove large amounts, which makes them useful for manure on livestock farms.

Alfalfa and other legumes are different. They fix their own nitrogen, so they don't need manure for nitrogen, though they use a lot of phosphorus and potassium. Manure on established alfalfa can encourage weeds and can add salts. Apply carefully, and follow the guidance of your state extension forage specialist.

On pastures, avoid applications right before grazing, and follow waiting periods in your state's rules or recommendations. Spread evenly. Cattle don't like grazing in the middle of a fresh pile, and neither do pathogens like the idea.

Crops that use it carefully

Soybeans and other legumes generally don't need manure for nitrogen. Applying heavy rates can cause excess growth and lodging in some conditions, and the extra nitrogen is mostly wasted. Phosphorus and potassium needs may justify manure on low-testing fields, but rates are usually modest. Check soil tests first.

Vegetables and fruit crops are another special case. Raw manure on crops eaten raw raises food safety concerns, and rules and waiting periods exist. If you sell produce, check the food safety requirements that apply, including USDA's Good Agricultural Practices programs and ask your buyer. If you're certified organic, check the National Organic Program rules on manure timing before harvest.

Match crops to field conditions

The best crop for manure on a given field is one that fits its soil and history. Fields low in phosphorus and potassium benefit more than fields already testing high. Sandy, low-organic-matter soils may gain more from the added organic matter, though they leach nitrogen more easily. Heavy clay soils can compact if you spread when wet.

Fields near streams, wells or tile inlets need extra care no matter the crop. Follow setbacks, and consider cover crops, buffer strips and incorporation to reduce runoff. Your local NRCS office can explain practices and possible cost-share.

Think about rotation too. Putting manure ahead of a heavy nitrogen user like corn, and giving soybeans or alfalfa credit for what's left, spreads nutrients over the sequence.

How to decide

Ask these questions of any field:

  1. What does the soil test say about phosphorus and potassium?
  2. What does the manure test say about nutrients and dry matter?
  3. What does the crop remove, and what does it need?
  4. Can I apply at the right time and with the right method?
  5. Are there setbacks, slopes or water concerns?

Answers drive the choice. A field that's high in phosphorus and growing soybeans is a poor place for more manure, however convenient. A field with low fertility headed into corn is a great one.

Don't let hauling distance decide everything. Hauling manure farther to a field that needs it beats overloading the field next to the barn. Your extension agent or a certified crop adviser can help you run the numbers. Most of them have heard every reason why the near field "just always gets it."