Which dairies are certified organic?
Check the certifier, not just the label
SAINT PAUL, Minnesota — Certified organic dairies are listed in public records, and you can check them yourself. The USDA keeps a searchable database of certified operations, and every certified farm has a certifying agency and a certificate you can ask to see. You don't have to take a farm's word, a marketing page or a carton's green leaf at face value. Here's how to find out which dairies are certified, and what the certification actually covers.
Use the official database
The AMS organic program oversees the National Organic Program and maintains the Organic Integrity Database, where you can look up certified farms and handlers by name and location. Search by state, product type or operation name. A listing shows the certifier, the scope of what's certified and the status. If a dairy isn't in the database, it isn't certified, whatever its packaging says.
Remember that a farm and the plant that bottles its milk are separate operations. Both may need certification, so look up both.
Know what the certification requires
Organic dairy standards cover how the cows are fed, housed and treated, and how the land is managed. In general terms, organic rules require organic feed, access to pasture during the grazing season, no routine antibiotics or synthetic growth hormones, and an organic system plan that an inspector reviews each year. The details are in the rules, and the AMS organic page is the authority. Read it directly rather than relying on a summary that might be out of date.
Certified organic doesn't mean small, and it doesn't mean pasture-only for the whole year, so read what the standard says before assuming.
Ask the farm for a certificate
Certified operations have a certificate listing what they're approved to produce. Ask to see it, or look at the certifier's own listing. Check that the certificate is current and that it covers dairy. A farm might be certified for crops but not milk, or certified for milk but not for processed products.
If a farm says it follows organic practices but isn't certified, that can be true. Small farms selling directly to customers sometimes qualify for an exemption from certification based on sales volume, though they can't call their products certified organic. Ask what the farm does and why it chose not to certify.
Look at transition and labels
Farms moving from conventional to organic go through a transition period before milk can be sold as organic. Products from a farm in transition can't carry the organic label. When you see labels, note the wording: "100 percent organic," "organic," and "made with organic ingredients" mean different things, and the AMS site explains them.
Terms like "natural," "farm fresh" or "hormone free" aren't the same as organic and don't carry the same checks.
Find organic dairies near you
Besides the database, look at your state's organic association, your extension office and the USDA Local Food Portal. ATTRA has helpful material on organic dairy systems. Farmers markets and co-ops often label their organic suppliers.
Read the label and ask questions
On a milk carton, look for the USDA organic seal and the name of the certifying agency near the address line. Ask the store or the processor which farms supply the milk. Many brands buy from several farms, and the label covers all of them. If you're a restaurant or a shop buying direct from a farm, ask for a copy of the current certificate and keep it on file. Organic certificates have an expiration, and products must match what the certificate lists. For consumers, the main point is that certification involves an annual review and a record trail, which is why the database lookup is worth the two minutes it takes.
If you want to visit, call first. Organic farms follow strict protocols for their animals and fields, and they'll tell you what they need from visitors. Most are happy to answer questions about grass, feed and cows.