Which deductions should I question?
Know what's allowed and what isn't
SHEBOYGAN, Wisconsin — You should question any deduction you can't explain, any that changed without notice, and any that isn't backed by a contract, a cooperative bylaw or a law. Many deductions are legitimate: hauling, checkoff assessments, cooperative dues and the like. But a legitimate-looking line can still be wrong in amount, rate or timing. Asking costs nothing, and the answer is your right as the person whose milk was sold.
Here's how to sort deductions into the ones to understand, the ones to verify and the ones to challenge.
The ones that are usually routine
Some deductions are common and often required. Hauling charges pay for pickup of your milk. Promotion and research assessments, often called checkoff, are required by program rules for dairy farmers. Cooperative membership dues, marketing fees and equity retains may come from your cooperative's bylaws.
Even routine deductions deserve a look. Check the rate against your contract or the published schedule. Verify that the amount is calculated on the correct volume. Ask whether the rate has changed and when. For background on how dairy checkoff works, see the U.S. Dairy site.
The ones to verify
Deductions that vary or that come from your buyer's discretion deserve more attention. Examples include hauling adjustments for stops or distance, fuel surcharges, testing fees, administrative charges, charges for supplies or services and capital retains.
Ask for the written basis for each one. A good buyer can point to a contract clause, a policy or a notice sent to members. If they can't, or if the explanation keeps changing, that's a reason to press. Also check whether the deduction is applied evenly to all producers or whether you're being treated differently from others in similar situations. The National Agricultural Law Center provides information on agricultural law topics that may help you understand your rights.
The ones to challenge
Question anything that:
- Appears without explanation or notice
- Increased sharply from one statement to the next
- Duplicates another charge
- Is calculated on volume you didn't ship
- Isn't mentioned in your contract or bylaws
- Appears to charge you for something you didn't receive
Keep calm and keep records. Pull your contract, your membership agreement and the last several statements. Highlight the line, write the date and amount, and note the difference from earlier statements. A clear, specific question gets a clear answer more often than a general complaint.
How to ask
Start with your field representative or the buyer's producer accounting department. Put the question in writing, by email or letter, and keep a copy. Be specific: name the statement date, the line, the amount and what you'd like explained or corrected.
If you get no satisfactory answer, ask for a meeting, and bring a neighbor or a trusted advisor if that makes it easier. If your milk is under a federal milk marketing order, you can also ask the Agricultural Marketing Service about rules governing payments and reporting for your order. Cooperatives usually have a board or a member committee where concerns can be raised.
Sample wording for your request
Keep the message short and factual. Something like: "On the statement dated for the last pickup period, line seven shows a deduction I can't match to my contract. Please send the written basis for it, the rate applied and the volume it was calculated on. I'd also like to know whether the rate changed from the prior statement." That's polite, specific and easy to answer. Save the reply with the statement it refers to, and note the date you asked. If you get a vague answer, ask the same question again and mention the first request.
Keep the relationship working
Most buyers want to get it right, and most errors are honest. Approach it as a request for explanation, not an accusation, and you'll usually get farther. But don't let a bad answer slide. A small error repeated over months and years adds up.
Review your statements regularly. Make a one-page summary of deductions by month and compare across the year, so changes show up. Talk to your extension specialist or a farm business advisor if you'd like help reading a contract. The farmers.gov working with us pages also explain where to find USDA help.
A question asked in writing is a question that gets answered. A grumble at the coffee shop gets you sympathy and nothing else.