Which DMC premiums pay off?
No way to know in advance
COLBY, Kansas — Nobody can tell you in advance which Dairy Margin Coverage premium will pay off, because payoff depends on future milk prices and feed costs that nobody knows. What you can do is look at how premiums and payments have compared historically, figure how much risk you're buying down and decide whether the price of that protection suits your farm. Anyone who tells you that one level is always the best deal is selling something, or at least repeating something.
Here's how to judge it without a crystal ball.
The honest framing
DMC premiums are the cost of protection, and in a year without payments, that cost looks wasted. That's how every risk tool works. Hail coverage that never pays isn't a bad deal. It's an unused one. So the real question is whether the premium is a fair price for the protection against the stretch that would hurt you, and whether you can afford that stretch without it. The Farm Service Agency publishes the current premium schedule, the payment calculations and, in many cases, historical information on payments. Use those as your base, not rumors.
How to look at past results
Take the premium schedule and compare each level's cost to what it would have paid over a long run of historical margins. University economists have done this analysis often, and sites like farmdoc daily and the Center for Farm Financial Management publish tools and write-ups. Look at several things: the average net return (payments minus premiums), the worst stretch, and how many years the coverage paid nothing. A level that paid off on average but only in one wild year isn't the same as one that paid modestly most years. Past results come from past conditions, so treat them as a guide to how often margins fall, not as a forecast.
Where premiums tend to look better or worse
In general, the lower coverage levels carry lower premiums per hundredweight, and the highest levels cost noticeably more. Whether a given step up in coverage pays for itself depends on the premium schedule at that time, which FSA sets under the law. Some producers find it makes sense to cover a larger share of production at a modest level. Others cover less production at a higher level. The mix that suits you depends on your cost structure and debt. Rather than quote a figure that may be stale, ask FSA for the current table and run both approaches through a calculator.
Look beyond the premium
A premium is cheap or expensive relative to what you'd lose without protection. Consider:
- Your break-even margin and how often the national margin falls below it
- How much cash you hold to cover a lean stretch
- Whether a lender requires risk coverage
- What you already pay for other protection
Also, remember that DMC pays on a national formula, so you may collect when your own farm is doing fine, or miss out when your farm is hurting. A farm that buys all its feed will track the national feed cost more closely than one that grows most of its own.
How to run your own comparison
- Get the current premium table from your county FSA office.
- Pull historical margin data from FSA or an extension source.
- Calculate what each level would have paid, minus the premium, for each past year.
- Check the downside year and ask whether your farm survives it.
- Compare that with the cost of other tools, such as revenue insurance from an agent through RMA.
The bottom line
The premium that pays off is the one that keeps you in business through a bad stretch at a price you can live with. In a good run it'll feel like money flushed down the drain, which is just what a smoke detector feels like until the day it isn't.