Which fiber sources suit dairy cows?

Forage first, byproducts as backup

ROCHESTER, Minnesota — The best fiber sources for dairy cows are good forages: alfalfa, grass hay or haylage, corn silage, small grain silage and sorghum silages, with straw in specific spots. Byproduct fibers such as soy hulls, beet pulp and corn gluten feed can supplement digestible fiber, but they don't replace forage particle length. Which fiber suits which group depends on its digestibility, particle size and what else is in the ration.

Understand the two jobs fiber does

Fiber does two separate jobs. It provides effective fiber, long enough to stimulate chewing and saliva, which buffers the rumen. It also provides digestible energy, as fiber that rumen bacteria ferment into volatile fatty acids. A feed can be good at one job and weak at the other. Straw is high on effectiveness and low on digestibility. Soy hulls are highly digestible but too fine to stimulate chewing much.

Forage sources and what they do

Cutting stage matters more than species. Mature forage has more lignin and less digestible fiber.

Use nonforage fiber with a purpose

Nonforage fiber sources include soy hulls, beet pulp, corn gluten feed, wheat middlings, citrus pulp, cottonseed hulls and whole cottonseed. These can displace part of the starch in a ration and help hold rumen pH steadier. Don't use them to cut forage below the minimum the cow needs.

Cost matters. Compare the price per unit of digestible fiber and net energy. USDA AMS Market News and local feed dealers give current prices, and I won't quote any here since they change by the week.

Measure what you're feeding

Test forages for NDF, NDF digestibility and lignin when the lab offers it. A particle separator checks the mixed ration. Ask whether your cows are sorting. A fiber source that looks good on the lab sheet but is too long to be eaten fully gets left in the bunk.

Match fiber to the group

Fresh and high-producing cows need highly digestible fiber for energy, balanced with enough effective fiber to keep the rumen healthy. Dry cows, heifers and late-lactation cows can use lower-quality fiber, which saves your best forage for the fresh pen. Close-up cows often benefit from some straw to control energy intake.

The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and Penn State Extension cover forage and fiber feeding, and University of Minnesota's Center for Farm Financial Management can help you run the numbers on forage and feed economics. AgMRC gives background on hay and forage markets.

Keep it consistent

Whatever you choose, buy and store it in a way that keeps the quality steady. Large changes in fiber source cause rumen disruption, so move gradually. Your cows are better judges of fiber than any ad copy, and they'll show their opinion at the bunk.