Which goat breed is best for milk?

Match the breed to your market

AUSTIN, Texas — No single goat breed wins for everybody. Saanens and Alpines usually lead on volume, Nubians lead on butterfat and protein, and Nigerian Dwarfs punch above their size on richness. The best breed is the one that fits what you're selling, how you manage the herd and what your buyer pays for.

The big breeds and what they do well

Saanen does are known for high volume and white coats that sunburn in strong sun. Alpines are hardy, adaptable and come in many colors, and they tend to milk well over a long lactation. LaManchas, with their tiny ear stubs, are valued for steady, even temperament and good milk with fair butterfat. Toggenburgs are among the oldest dairy breeds, generally lower in volume and moderate in components. Oberhasli are calm, Swiss-type goats that milk solidly. Treat these as general tendencies, not guarantees, since individual lines vary a lot.

Nubians and the component question

Nubians typically give less milk than the Swiss breeds but with higher butterfat and protein. If you make cheese and your buyer pays on components, or you simply get more cheese per gallon, that matters. If you ship fluid milk and get paid by volume, Nubians may disappoint. Their long ears and sometimes louder voices are the other trade-offs.

Miniature breeds

Nigerian Dwarf goats give small amounts of very rich milk and fit small acreage. They're popular with home dairies and soap makers, and they breed year-round, which can stretch out milk supply. Their small teats can make machine milking harder and hand milking slower per quart. Crosses of dwarf and standard breeds, such as Mini-Alpines or Mini-Nubians, are common, but check records for the specific animals instead of trusting the label.

Look at records, not only breed names

Within any breed, the spread between a great line and a mediocre line is bigger than the spread between breeds. The American Dairy Goat Association runs milk test and linear appraisal programs, and Dairy Herd Improvement testing is available in many areas. Ask sellers for lactation records of the dam and the sire's daughters, plus udder scores. A doe with a well-attached, capacious udder and good feet will outlast a flashy one with a pendulous bag.

Questions to ask before you buy

  1. What am I paid for, volume or components?
  2. What's my climate? Heat and humidity are tougher on some lines, and cold is rough on young Nigerian kids.
  3. How will I milk, by hand or machine, and do the teats suit that?
  4. Does the seller test for CAE, caseous lymphadenitis and Johne's, and can I see results?
  5. How many does do I need to keep the milk flowing through the year?

For breed-neutral management, the ATTRA small ruminant resources and your state extension service are useful, and Cornell Small Farms has beginner material. Pick a breed, buy the best individuals you can afford and be wary of any seller who says their breed is simply the best. Every seller says that, and most of them also own the goats in question.