Which inflations wear fastest?
Material, milkings and cows decide
STILLWATER, Oklahoma — Rubber inflations, which dairies also call liners, generally wear out faster than silicone ones, and cheaper or thinner designs wear out faster than thicker ones. But the real answer depends on how many milkings they go through, how hot and dirty the wash is, and what your cows' teats do to them. There is no ranking you can trust without checking against your own milking count.
If you want a quick rule, assume liners wear out sooner than they look. Fatigue is invisible until the cow starts telling you about it.
Rubber versus silicone
Natural and synthetic rubber blends are common and affordable, and they soften, crack, and lose their shape as they age and as they absorb fats. Silicone liners tend to last longer by milking count, resist fat and chemicals, and hold their shape, but they cost more and may feel and perform differently in the cow. Some silicone liners are harder to fit or can be slippery.
Compare cost per milking, not price per liner. A liner that lasts twice as long at twice the price costs the same but saves labor and downtime. Check the manufacturer's stated life and ask for the conditions behind that number.
What speeds up wear
Several things can shorten liner life: hot wash water, strong acid or chlorinated chemicals, high sanitizer concentration, fat from milk, teat dip contact, sunlight, and heat in storage. Using the wrong cleaning chemicals for the material can age liners prematurely.
Overstretching or poor fitting also hurts. A liner mounted too tight in the shell wears faster and may twist. Frequent pulsation rates add flex cycles. Rough handling and dropped units damage the rubber too.
Cows and herd differences
Teat size and shape affect wear. Large or rough teats stress liners differently from small ones. Heavy milking cows put more flow through each liner. Herds using a lot of barrier dips can see more wear on certain liner materials, so ask the manufacturer about compatibility with your dip.
Ask your dealer which liners suit your herd. Mixing sizes in a herd with variable teats can mean compromises. Keep records so you can compare brands or materials on your own farm.
Signs a liner is worn
Look for cracks, rough or sticky inner surfaces, a barrel that has lost its shape, thin or discolored spots, and a loss of elasticity. A liner that has stretched out might slip, and one that has hardened can cause sore teat ends. Slower milking, more falling units, rising strippings and worsening teat ends may all be signs.
Rotating liners, a practice some farms use, is something to ask about; follow the manufacturer's instruction. Mark liners with the date and milking count where you can.
Track and test
Record the date of each change and the milkings since. Many dairies replace liners on a set count rather than waiting for failure. If you are trying new liners, test them on a group of cows and watch teat ends and cell counts.
The National Mastitis Council has milking system information, and your dealer should give you written replacement intervals. Your extension dairy specialist, contacted through eXtension, may know what works locally. AABP can connect you with a dairy veterinarian who looks at teat ends.
When in doubt, replace sooner. A set of liners costs less than a round of mastitis treatment. Keep a spare set in the shop, because liners always give up on a day when the dealer is closed.