Which lagoon covers work best?

Match the cover to the job

LANCASTER, Pennsylvania — No single lagoon cover wins everywhere. The best one depends on whether you want odor control, gas capture for energy, or just less rainwater in the pit. Those are three different jobs, and the cover that does one well can do another poorly. Start by deciding what you're buying.

Natural and floating covers

The cheapest option is an organic crust, like chopped straw or a naturally forming mat of fibrous solids. It reduces odor some and costs little, but it breaks down, blows around, and gets destroyed any time you agitate. Treat it as a low-cost partial measure, not a permanent fix. Floating inorganic materials, like plastic balls or tiles, can shade the surface and cut wind effects, but performance claims vary and they can complicate pumping and cleaning. Ask any vendor for independent university data, not a brochure.

Impermeable floating covers

A geomembrane cover floats on the lagoon surface and is anchored at the edges. It seals the liquid from the air, controls odor, and keeps rain out of the lagoon so you handle less water. If it's designed for gas collection, it also allows biogas capture, which makes it relevant if you're planning a covered lagoon digester. Questions to ask:

  1. How does the cover shed rainwater, and what pumps handle it?
  2. What happens when gas builds under it, and how is it vented or flared?
  3. What's the warranty, and what voids it?
  4. How do you agitate or clean solids from under it?

Climate matters. Snow loads, ice and wind affect design, so a cover proven in a mild climate may not suit a northern one.

Fixed or rigid covers

Concrete or steel-framed covers on tanks are the most durable choice, usually sized for new structures rather than retrofitted onto an earthen lagoon. They cost more, work well with digesters, and let you manage gas and odor tightly. They also require confined-space safety planning for any entry, because manure gas is not a joke. Review OSHA agriculture resources and the NIOSH agriculture pages before anyone goes near a covered structure.

Match the cover to your lagoon shape and management

Long rectangular lagoons with steep walls are easier to cover than large irregular ones. A lagoon you agitate often needs a cover that tolerates that. A lagoon that fills quickly with solids needs access for removal. If you haven't separated solids, a cover can turn cleanout into a bigger job.

Where the money and advice come from

Costs, incentives and approved designs change, and I won't quote any. NRCS has conservation practice standards for covers on waste storage, and your local service center can tell you whether the practice is eligible for cost-share through farmers.gov conservation. Check NRCS for the standards and your state's engineer for any permit. Your extension office or farms.extension.wisc.edu can point to published field evaluations of cover types in cold climates.

A short decision path

Get two or three quotes, talk to farms that have had the cover for several winters, and ask what they'd do differently. That last question is the cheapest research you'll do.