Which manure spreaders work best?
It depends on your manure and your acres
CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa — The best manure spreader is the one that matches your manure type, your acreage, your soil and your labor, and that you can calibrate and maintain. There's no single winner. Solid manure, slurry and semi-solid manure need different equipment, and a machine that suits a large dairy may be a poor fit for a small beef lot.
Rather than recommend brands, this guide lays out the main types, what each does well, and what to ask a dealer before you buy.
Solid manure spreaders
Box spreaders, often called manure spreaders, use a conveyor floor and beaters to throw solid manure behind the machine. They handle bedded pack, dry lot scrapings and stacked manure. Horizontal beater models are common and spread a wide, shallow pattern. Vertical beater units chop and throw more material and may handle bulky, strawy loads, though patterns and wear differ.
Look at capacity, how well the unit deals with long straw and frozen chunks, how even the pattern is, and how easy it is to clean. Ground-driven models are simple and low cost. Hydraulic or PTO-driven units give more control over rate. Spreader width and overlap decide uniformity, so test the pattern with tarps or catch pans.
Nebraska's Tractor Test Lab reports on tractors, which helps size the power you'll need to pull a loaded spreader.
Liquid manure tankers and injection
Tank spreaders carry slurry and spread it by splash plate, or by injection or incorporation tools. Splash plates are simple and cheap, but they spread manure on the surface where more nitrogen can be lost to the air and odor tends to be higher. Injectors and drag hoses place manure below the surface or on it in bands, which cuts odor and loss and can allow application in growing crops, though they need more power and more care.
Drag hose systems move manure from storage to the field by hose, cutting down on heavy tanker traffic and soil compaction. They suit larger operations, and many are run by custom applicators. Hiring a custom applicator can be wiser than buying equipment you'll use a few days a year.
Ask about pump capacity, agitation, tank construction, flotation tires and how well the system handles foreign material like sand or long fibers.
Matching the machine to your farm
Think through your situation:
- What type of manure do I handle, and how much?
- How many acres do I cover, and how far from the storage?
- What are my soil conditions? Wet, heavy or hilly ground changes the choice.
- What tractor and labor do I have?
- What do my state's rules require? Some regulations favor injection or restrict surface application.
- What's the budget, and would custom hire be cheaper?
Soil compaction matters. Heavy loaded tankers on wet ground do lasting damage. Wide tires, lower inflation pressures where the manufacturer allows it, fewer passes and drag hoses all reduce risk.
Your NRCS service center can tell you whether cost-share programs apply to equipment that reduces nutrient loss. Ask before you buy, not after.
Questions to ask a dealer
Don't buy on looks. Ask for a field demonstration with your manure if possible. Ask what real-world application rates the machine can hit, how it's calibrated, and how the manufacturer recommends checking uniformity. Request details about wear parts, such as chains, beaters and floor slats, and what they cost to replace. Ask about service in your area and parts availability.
Find out what tractor horsepower is needed when full, on hills, and in wet or frozen conditions. Check hitch weight and PTO requirements, and confirm that your tractor can brake the loaded unit safely on slopes. Rollovers and runaway spreaders injure farmers every year, and the OSHA agriculture pages and NIOSH cover PTO and equipment safety.
Buy, borrow or hire
Compare owning against custom application. Ownership gives control over timing, but you carry the cost of the machine, repairs and labor. Custom hire gives modern equipment without the capital, though you depend on someone else's schedule. Used equipment can be a good value if you inspect it, but check the floor chain, gearbox and bed condition.
Whichever way you go, calibrate and keep records. A great spreader that applies the wrong rate is just an expensive way to make a mistake.
Visit your state extension office and farm equipment demonstrations for hands-on looks. Neighbors with similar operations are another good source, and they'll happily tell you what broke last spring.