Which manure storage system suits my farm?

Match the pit to your barn

LANCASTER, Pennsylvania — The storage system that suits your farm is the one that fits how your manure is collected, how much bedding goes in it, how your land is laid out, and what your soils and neighbors will allow. There isn't a best type in general. There are only good matches and bad ones.

Here are the main options and the questions that separate them.

Slurry tanks and below-barn pits

Below-barn pits and above-ground tanks hold manure, urine and a bit of water as a slurry. They work well for freestall barns with scrape or slatted floors and little added water. Covered structures keep rain out, which cuts the total volume you haul. They cost more up front, need confined-space safety around agitation (manure gas kills quickly), and need good agitation before pumping. Get fresh air and a gas plan in place before anyone goes near them. The OSHA agriculture page and NIOSH agriculture resources cover manure storage hazards.

Earthen basins and lagoons

Earthen basins are cheaper per gallon of storage and suit farms with lots of flush or wash water. Lagoons rely on soil type or a liner to prevent seepage, and the design must fit local standards. They collect rain, so volume grows. They also require space, setbacks from wells and streams, and careful management of odor. Soils with high water tables or fractured bedrock may rule them out entirely.

Dry stack and solid storage

If your barn uses bedded packs, or you separate solids, you can stack the dry material on a pad. Dry stacking needs a surface that doesn't leak, a roof or cover where rules require it, and a plan for runoff. Solid storage is handy for composting or for storing material before a trip to distant fields. It's not a good fit if most of your material is liquid.

Compare cost, labor and risk

Ask what each option costs to build, what it costs to empty, and what happens when something goes wrong. A concrete tank has low seepage risk and a high price. A basin has lower capital cost and more weather exposure. Count labor too: some systems need daily scraping, some need only periodic agitation. Also look at flexibility; a system that holds six months lets you wait out a wet spring.

Check what your site and rules allow

Soil depth, distance to water, floodplain status and zoning can eliminate options before you finish the sketch. Look at your soils in the Web Soil Survey, then talk to your local NRCS office and your state agriculture or environmental agency. Ask extension for case studies from farms near your herd size. Several university programs, including Penn State Extension, publish plain-language guides to manure storage types.

Visit two or three farms that use the systems you're considering. Ask the owner what he'd do differently. Farmers are rarely shy about this, and an hour in a truck cab beats a week of brochures.

Write down the answers, then bring them to an engineer along with your herd numbers, planned expansion and land base. The design they hand back should match your actual operation instead of a generic one.