Which policies cover milk dumping?

Where losses from dumped milk might be covered

CANANDAIGUA, New York — No single policy covers all milk dumping, and which one pays depends on why the milk was dumped. Milk poured out because of contamination may fit the Dairy Indemnity Payment Program. Milk lost because a blizzard or flood kept the truck from reaching your farm may fit certain disaster programs. Milk dumped because the plant cut your quota or the market collapsed usually isn't covered by anything except contract terms and price protection you bought ahead of time. The details change by year and by program, so this article sorts the possibilities and tells you where to confirm what applies to you.

Contamination: the indemnity program

If a health authority orders your milk off the market because of a covered residue, the Farm Service Agency's dairy indemnity program may pay for what you lost. This is the narrowest and clearest case. The milk has to be pulled for a covered contaminant, and the cause generally can't be your own misuse. It's not meant for milk discarded because of antibiotics you administered or ordinary quality problems like high somatic cell count. Start at your county FSA office, found through the Farmers.gov locator, and ask whether your situation fits.

Disaster and weather: livestock disaster programs

When milk can't be shipped or must be dumped because of an eligible weather event or disaster, FSA livestock disaster programs may apply. One program some dairy producers have used is the Emergency Assistance for Livestock, Honeybees, and Farm-raised Fish Program, which covers certain losses not handled by other programs. Whether milk dumping counts, what condition qualifies, and what documentation is required are program-specific questions, so ask FSA directly rather than rely on a summary like this. Look through Farmers.gov protection and recovery for the current list. Tell FSA about the loss promptly, because notice requirements exist.

Insurance and margin tools

Some products people assume cover dumped milk don't. Dairy Margin Coverage pays based on a national margin formula, not on the volume you actually lost. Dairy Revenue Protection, sold through crop insurance agents and backed by the Risk Management Agency, protects against drops in price or revenue as defined by the policy, not physical loss of milk. Read the policy language at RMA. Your commercial farm property and liability policies may include coverage for spoilage after a power outage or equipment breakdown, but many exclude it unless you added an endorsement. Pull your policies out and read the exclusions; then call your agent and ask about milk specifically.

Contracts and processor terms

If your plant told you to dump, ask for it in writing. Co-op bylaws and handler contracts sometimes address what happens when the plant can't take milk, including whether the plant pays something for forced dumping. Sometimes the answer is nothing. Sometimes the plant manages through base programs, quotas, or supply management rules. Understand these before a crisis, not during one. If you're a member of a co-op, ask your delegate or field rep what the policy is and whether it has been used. Your state milk marketing agency or Federal Milk Marketing Order administrator might also hold answers. Details are on AMS dairy pages.

A practical sorting order

When something happens, move in order:

  1. Document everything the day it happens.
  2. Notify your processor, then your insurance agent.
  3. Notify FSA if disaster or contamination applies.
  4. Ask a farm-law resource such as the National Agricultural Law Center if someone else caused it.

If a neighbor's spray or a utility's fault caused the loss, there may be a claim against them, and that is a lawyer's question, not a program question.

Bottom line: the policy that covers dumped milk depends on the cause, so identify the cause first and match it to the program second.