Which risk management tools suit dairies?

A short menu for dairy farms

PLAINVIEW, Texas — Dairies have several risk management tools to choose from: federal margin coverage, federal revenue insurance, forward contracts, futures and options, feed contracting, disaster programs, and ordinary property and liability insurance. Which ones suit you depends on your biggest exposure, your cash flow, and how much time you have to manage them. Most farms use a mix, not a single tool.

Here's a sorting guide for the main tools, with the questions that tell you whether each one belongs on your farm.

Margin protection

The Dairy Margin Coverage program, run by the Farm Service Agency, pays when the national margin between the all-milk price and a standard feed cost falls below your chosen coverage level. It suits dairies whose profit depends on that gap and that want a low-maintenance safety net.

Its limits: the margin is a national formula, not your own, and payments are calculated monthly from published data. If your feed costs or milk price differ a lot from the national figures, the program may protect you less than you think. Ask your county office about current coverage tiers and rates, and use the farmers.gov service center locator to find the office.

Revenue protection

Dairy Revenue Protection, overseen by the Risk Management Agency, pays when covered revenue falls below a guarantee. It's a good fit for a dairy with debt payments that depend on a minimum milk revenue and that sells milk on class or component prices. It's less useful if your milk price is already fixed or if feed is your main worry.

You buy it through an approved agent by quarter, so timing matters. Ask about sales closing dates and about how declared production is handled. Compare the premium against the protection you'd get in a bad scenario.

Pricing tools

Forward contracts with your buyer set a price, or a pricing formula, for a defined volume. Futures and options let you take a position that offsets a drop in milk prices. Forward contracts are simple but inflexible; futures and options offer more control but require a broker, margin management and a good understanding of basis risk.

If you're new to these, start small. A farm that prices a modest portion of its milk and learns the process beats one that jumps in too far and panics. The farmdoc Daily site has plenty of plain-language marketing analysis.

Feed and input management

Since feed is the biggest cost for most dairies, feed risk deserves its own plan. Options include forward contracting feed, growing more of your own, storing more forage, diversifying suppliers and working with a nutritionist on flexible rations.

Margin tools help with feed price movement indirectly, while feed contracts address it directly. Ask your supplier about price protection, delivery terms and what happens if you can't take delivery. The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker site has budgeting tools to compare strategies.

Everything else that can go wrong

Not every risk comes from the market. Weather, disease, fire, injuries and family changes can sink a dairy as quickly as a price drop. Protect against these with property and liability insurance, workers' compensation, a farm succession plan and a cash reserve. For weather and disaster losses, check programs listed at farmers.gov protection and recovery.

A short checklist helps:

  1. Rank your top three risks.
  2. Match one tool to each.
  3. Price the tools and compare with what you can afford.
  4. Write down who's responsible for monitoring each one.
  5. Review every year.

A sample starter plan

A mid-sized dairy with moderate debt might begin like this: enroll in margin coverage at a level matched to breakeven, add revenue protection for the quarters with the most risk, forward contract a portion of feed, keep property and liability coverage current, and hold a cash cushion. A smaller farm might skip the pricing tools and rely on margin coverage, feed purchasing discipline and a good relationship with its lender. Neither plan is right or wrong; they're matched to different farms. Start with what you can manage and add tools as your comfort grows.

Put someone in charge

Risk plans fail when nobody owns them. Decide who tracks deadlines, who calls the agent, who talks to the lender. On a family farm that may be you, and the answer should be written down anyway.

Ask your lender, FSA office, agent and extension specialist to review your plan. They each see something different. And remember that a tool you understand and use beats a fancier one that sits in a drawer. Risk management isn't glamorous, but it's the difference between a bad year and a lost farm.