Which selection index suits my goals?
Match the index to your herd's income
KEWAUNEE, Wisconsin — A selection index is one number that combines many traits, weighted by how much each is worth. In dairy, the indexes you'll see come from national evaluators and from the studs. They don't all weight traits the same way. Picking the right one means picking the index whose weights look most like your farm's income and costs.
There's no single winner. Here's how to compare indexes and choose one you can live with.
Understand what an index does
An index takes traits like milk, fat, protein, fertility, health, longevity and body type, assigns each a weight and adds them up into a ranking. The weights reflect assumptions about prices and costs. If your farm's reality differs from those assumptions, a different index may fit better. Most evaluators publish what's in their index, so you can read the weights.
Check how the weights match your income
Ask what your milk is paid on. If your processor pays heavily on components, an index that stresses fat and protein fits. If you ship fluid milk with volume emphasis, the balance shifts. Look at your own costs: fertility problems, vet bills and early culling. If those cost you a lot, favor indexes that give health and fertility real weight. Use your milk check and your records to guide the choice. For information on how milk is priced, see the AMS Market News.
Compare indexes side by side
Take a list of bulls you like and look at where they rank on two or three indexes. If a bull ranks high on all, he's a safe choice. If one bull jumps up on one index and falls on another, find out which traits drive the difference. Ask your stud rep to explain it in plain terms.
Think about your system
A grazing herd, a robotic milking herd and a large confinement herd have different needs. Grazers may want smaller, fertile, efficient cows; robot herds may want good udder shape and milking speed. Pick or adjust indexes accordingly. Some studs publish custom indexes or help create them.
Use the index as a filter
Many breeders use an index to create a short list, then check individual traits that matter most to them. For example, a bull with a strong index but a poor trait you're struggling with, like feet, may not be right. Set minimums for key traits. Also watch the reliability figure that goes with each bull's number.
Resources to check
- The national dairy genetic evaluation reports and their trait weights
- Your stud's and co-op's published indexes
- Extension dairy breeding material
- Dairy Markets and checkoff resources
- Your vet, for health trait priorities
Review as the market changes
Prices and costs shift, and evaluators update their indexes. Check what's current on each evaluator's site rather than trusting an old catalog. Revisit your choice every year or two. Keep a log of the bulls you used and how their daughters perform, since your own herd results are the final test of an index.
If you're unsure, ask two or three experts why they'd pick a given index. Notice where they agree.