Which sheep breed produces the best milk?

It depends on what you mean by best

COBLESKILL, New York — The East Friesian is the breed most often named for the highest milk volume, and the Lacaune is a close contender and widely used in Europe for cheese. But "best" depends on whether you want volume, milk solids, hardiness, or adaptability to your climate and management. Most North American dairy flocks use East Friesian or Lacaune genetics, often crossed with local sheep or with each other. Here's how to decide what suits your operation.

Volume versus milk solids

East Friesian ewes are known for high volume. Cheesemakers often care more about fat and protein, since those determine how much cheese a given amount of milk makes. Breeds that give less volume but richer milk can yield comparable cheese per ewe. If you sell milk by volume to a processor, ask whether your buyer pays on components. If you make your own cheese, solids matter more than gallons.

Milk composition changes during lactation and with feed, so a single test day doesn't tell you much. Ask breeders for records across a full lactation, and compare animals tested under similar management. Breed averages are a guide, but your flock's results are what count.

The main dairy breeds

The East Friesian has a reputation for volume but can be less hardy in harsh conditions and sometimes struggles in hot, humid climates. The Lacaune was developed in France largely for cheese production, with milk well suited to it, and it has performed well in North American dairies. Other dairy breeds exist with their own followings, such as those from the Mediterranean region, which are often valued for rich milk and adaptability.

Crossbreeding is common. A ewe that's part dairy breed and part hardy local sheep may produce less than a purebred, but may live longer and handle the weather better. Ask breeders in your region what's working. Sheep industry groups like the American Sheep Industry Association and your state sheep association can connect you with breeders.

Climate, forage and management

A high-producing ewe needs feed to match. Dairy sheep on poor pasture or a thin ration won't reach their genetic potential, and a breed with high potential can underperform if you can't feed her. Think about your forage base, your barn, your winter and your summer heat. A breed that thrived in a mild European valley may need adjustment in a Dakota winter.

Extension specialists and veterinarians with small ruminant experience can help. The ATTRA sustainable agriculture program has resources on small ruminant production and pasture-based systems. Use them to compare your resources to the requirements of each breed.

How to evaluate a breeder

Production records matter more than a breed name. Ask for lactation yields, lactation length, fat and protein tests, lambing rates, udder health and culling reasons. Ask how many ewes are in the flock, and whether the animals are recorded in a milk-testing program. Visit in person. Look at udder shape, teat placement and feet, since a ewe with a poorly attached udder or bad feet won't last.

Ask about disease testing and the flock's history. Because sheep dairying takes years to build, a good breeder is worth a bit more per animal. Be wary of anyone selling a breed name without records.

Match the breed to your plan

If you plan to ship to a cheese plant, ask the buyer which genetics they prefer or require. If you make cheese yourself, think about your product: some cheeses want the richest milk, and others benefit from higher volume. If you're starting with a small budget, buying a few high-quality ewes and a good ram, or using artificial insemination where available, can build a flock faster than buying a large number of average animals.

One more habit pays off: write down what each ewe does on your own pasture and ration, not just what her pedigree promises. Two ewes of the same breed can differ by a wide margin in milk and in how well they hold up through a long season, and only your records will show which is which. Ask your cheesemaker or milk buyer to taste and test samples from different ewe groups, too.

Whichever breed you choose, plan to cull hard. The best milk producer on your farm will be whichever ewes you keep records on and breed from, year after year. Breed gets you started. Records and selection get you the milk.