Which systems treat dairy wastewater?

Match treatment to site and herd size

GOODING, Idaho — Several systems treat dairy wastewater, including settling basins, lagoons, constructed wetlands, vegetated treatment areas, aerobic systems and anaerobic digesters. None is right everywhere. The one that fits depends on herd size, climate, soils, state rules and what you want from treatment. A small herd with a good spreading base may need only a settling basin and storage. A large dairy near sensitive water may need something more intensive. Start by writing down how much wastewater you make, where it has to go, and what your state expects before you price anything.

Settling basins and storage

A settling basin slows water so solids drop out before liquid moves on. Often it is the first step ahead of a lagoon or storage pond, and it's the cheapest way to cut solids load. Basins need regular cleanout, and the cleaned-out material has to go somewhere that your plan allows. A storage pond or lagoon holds liquid until you can spread it on crops. These are common and well understood, but they must be designed to local standards, including liners, size and separation from water. Your NRCS service center can explain technical standards and direct you to design help.

Lagoons and biological treatment

Lagoons treat wastewater biologically over time, with microbes breaking down organic matter. Anaerobic lagoons do this without added air; aerobic systems add oxygen, which cuts odor but adds energy cost. Odor, sludge and climate all affect performance. Cold weather slows biological action, so a design that works in a mild climate may disappoint in a northern one. Ask an extension engineer how lagoon design in your region accounts for temperature and sludge buildup. Sizing errors are a common cause of trouble, so don't eyeball it, and don't assume a lagoon treats everything to the point you can discharge it.

Vegetated treatment and wetlands

Vegetated treatment areas and constructed wetlands let plants and soil take up nutrients and slow water. They need land, careful design and ongoing management such as harvest of vegetation. They aren't a cure for undiluted waste, and most work best after solids have been removed. Some states have specific requirements or limits on their use for dairy wastewater, so check with your state agency before you plan one. Research from land-grant universities, found through Extension, describes how these systems have performed on working farms. Winter performance and flooding risk are the questions to press on.

Digesters and advanced systems

Anaerobic digesters capture biogas from manure and wastewater and can reduce odor and some pathogens. They carry high capital cost, need skilled operation and usually work best at larger scale or where energy markets support them. Other advanced systems can concentrate nutrients or remove them from the liquid stream. They're costly and may need a nutrient management plan that accounts for the products they create. Ask about operating costs, labor and what happens to the residual solids and liquid. Check farmers.gov conservation for programs that may help with some waste system costs, and confirm current availability with your local office.

Choose with a checklist

Ask these questions before you commit:

  1. What does my state require for permits and design?
  2. How much wastewater do I produce, and how does it vary through the year?
  3. What are my soils, depth to groundwater and distance to surface water?
  4. How much cropland can take the liquid at agronomic rates?
  5. What will it cost to build, run and maintain, and who will service it?

Cost and labor deserve their own honest look. Each system has a build cost, a yearly operating cost and a labor load, and the labor is the one people underestimate. A system that needs daily attention will get skipped during haying, calving or harvest. Choose something your crew can run during your busiest week, and ask the designer which parts need a skilled technician and which you can handle yourself.

Plan for the sludge and solids that treatment creates. Every system makes some, and they need to be removed, stored and applied under your plan. Ask how often cleanout happens, what equipment it takes and where the material goes. Also ask what happens in an extreme rain or a long power outage. A system that fails gently is worth more than one that fails loudly.

Bring those answers to your planner and engineer. Then visit a working system of the type you're considering and ask the owner what they'd change. The cheapest system on paper is often the most expensive one after the first inspection.