How do I compare dealer diagnostic fees?

Ask what the fee covers

DODGE CITY, Kansas — To compare dealer diagnostic fees, find out exactly what each fee includes, how it's calculated and whether it's applied to the repair if you go ahead. A diagnostic charge is not one standardized thing. Two dealers can quote similar-sounding fees that cover very different amounts of work.

Understand how fees are set

Some shops charge a flat diagnostic fee, others bill by the hour with a minimum, and some roll diagnostics into the repair if you approve the work. Ask whether the fee covers connecting a scan tool, testing components, a road or field test, travel to your farm and a written report. Ask whether it changes with the type of machine or the complexity of the problem. Always request this in writing, since a verbal range may turn out to mean something different on the invoice.

Ask about the credit toward repairs

A common question is whether the diagnostic fee is credited if you let the shop do the repair. Policies differ, so ask each dealer. Also ask what happens if you decline the repair. Find out whether you'll get a written diagnosis you can take to another shop, with part numbers and a labor estimate. That document has value, and a fee that buys you nothing but a verbal opinion is less attractive.

Compare shop and field diagnostics

Diagnosing in the shop means hauling the machine or part, but the shop has tools, parts and manuals handy. Field diagnosis saves hauling and downtime but may involve travel time and mileage charges, and a technician may not have everything on the truck. Ask each dealer about both, and find out how long each takes at the time of year you need it. In busy season, ask about priority and how they handle emergencies.

Compare the technician and the tools

A cheaper fee from a shop without the right software or training may cost more if the diagnosis is wrong. Ask whether technicians are trained on your type of equipment and whether the shop has the diagnostic software for it. Ask how they handle electronic fault codes, and whether they'll show you the readings. Talk to neighbors who have used the shop. A good diagnosis is worth paying for when it stops you from replacing the wrong part.

Set a spending limit

Ask the dealer to call you before work goes past the diagnostic stage, and to give a written estimate before repairs begin. State a limit, in writing if possible, so there are no surprises. Ask about storage fees if you leave the machine, and about what happens if the problem can't be reproduced. Keep copies of all estimates and invoices; the IRS Publication 225 explains farm recordkeeping for repairs.

Do a quick self-check first

Before you call, check the obvious: fuel, filters, battery connections, fuses, fluid levels and any fault codes shown on the display. Write down when the problem happens, what the machine was doing and what you've tried. Good notes shorten diagnostic time. For machinery cost planning, farmdoc daily and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker have farm economics resources.

Questions to ask on the phone

When you call, have your machine details ready and ask a short, specific list. What's your diagnostic fee and what does it cover? Is it charged per hour or flat? Is it credited toward repairs? Do you charge for travel? Will you call me with a written estimate before starting repairs? Can I get a copy of the diagnosis if I decide to go elsewhere? How soon can you look at it? Write down the answers and the name of the person you spoke with. Then call a second shop and ask the same questions in the same order. That way, the numbers and terms line up and you aren't comparing apples to hay bales.

Remember that a good diagnosis often saves more than it costs. A technician who finds the real cause on the first visit prevents a string of swapped parts. If a shop's diagnosis doesn't make sense to you, ask them to explain the test results, and don't be shy about getting a second opinion on a costly repair.

A fee is only a good deal when you know what you're buying. Ask, compare in writing and keep the paperwork.