How do I compare dealer parts return policies?
Ask before you buy
ROANOKE, Virginia — To compare dealer parts return policies, ask each dealer for the policy in writing and look at what can be returned, how long you have, what condition the part must be in and what fees apply. Policies on farm parts are often stricter than you'd expect, so learn the rules before you order, not after the box arrives.
Time limits and condition
Ask how many days you have to return a part and when the clock starts, such as the day you order or the day it arrives. Ask whether the part must be unused, uninstalled and in its original packaging. Some dealers won't accept parts that have been mounted, even briefly. Ask whether you need the invoice and what happens if you lose it.
Restocking fees and shipping
Many dealers charge restocking fees, especially for special-order parts, and some don't take returns on those at all. Ask whether a fee applies and how it's calculated. Ask who pays return shipping, and whether freight on the original order is refunded. For heavy parts, shipping charges can be large, so look at that part of the policy closely. Compare the terms side by side across dealers.
Special orders, electrical and core parts
Parts ordered specially for you may be final sale. Electrical parts and electronic modules often can't be returned once installed or if the seal is broken, since a returned part can't be proven good. Some parts carry a core charge, meaning you return the old part to get a deposit back. Ask what condition the core must be in and by when it must be returned.
Wrong part or defective part
Ask separately about returns for a wrong part ordered, a wrong part supplied and a defective part. Dealers may handle each differently. Ask whether you get a refund, store credit or exchange, and how long processing takes. Give the dealer your serial number and part numbers in writing when ordering, so errors are easier to sort out. Keep all documents.
Check the warranty too
A return policy covers sending the part back; a warranty covers a part that fails. Ask what warranty applies, how long it lasts and what you must do to claim it. Ask whether labor is covered if the part fails. Check whether using the part on the wrong machine, or an improper install, voids coverage. See the National Agricultural Law Center for background on farm law matters.
Put it in writing
Get the policy on the quote, invoice or in an email. Ask the counter person to note on the order that you've been told the policy. If you're buying a lot of parts, ask whether a standing arrangement with different terms is available for established accounts. Keep records of purchases and returns for tax time; see IRS Publication 225.
Reduce the chance of returns
Take photos and measurements, and match numbers from your manual. Compare the old part to the new one before installing. Ask the dealer to confirm fit based on your serial number. For help on machinery costs and planning, see Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker.
A short list to ask at the counter
Before you pay, ask five things. Can this part be returned if it doesn't fit? How many days do I have? Is there a restocking fee? Who pays return freight? Is there a core charge and what's the deadline? Write the answers on the receipt or ask the counter person to note them. If you're ordering something expensive or special-order, ask whether the dealer will confirm fit based on your serial number. Keep the original packaging until you're sure the part works, and don't install anything you may want to return until you've compared it with the old part side by side.
Finally, remember that policies can be negotiable for regular customers. If you buy steadily from a dealer, ask whether they'll accept returns on special orders or waive restocking fees when you're a good account. It costs nothing to ask politely.
The best return is the one you never make. The second best is the one where the policy was already in writing.
