How do I compare dealer rental fleets?

Look at the machines, the terms and the backup

WICHITA, Kansas — A dealer's rental fleet can fill a gap in your equipment lineup without a purchase, but fleets differ in what they have, how well it's kept and how the rental terms read. Comparing them takes more than checking which has the machine you want. Here's a way to line up two or three dealers and see which one actually serves you best.

List what you need and when

Write down the equipment type, size, attachments, rental length and time of year. Note the delivery method: will you pick it up or have it delivered? Note your tractor or loader compatibility if you're renting attachments. Think about whether you might want to rent to own, and ask each dealer if that's an option. Dealers can't promise equipment they don't have when you need it, so ask about reservations for peak seasons.

Check the fleet

Ask what's in the fleet and how old it is. Ask how often machines are serviced and who does it. Look at the machines in person if you can: check the condition of tires, hoses, shields, seats, cabs and safety features. See whether maintenance records are available. Ask how the dealer handles breakdowns during a rental, including how fast they'd replace a machine. A tidy, well-greased fleet usually suggests the same care in service. A machine that's been beaten up by prior renters should raise questions.

Compare terms in writing

Ask for the rental agreement ahead of time and read it. Look at how the rental period is counted, such as daily, weekly or by hour, and what hour limits apply. Look at fuel policy, delivery and pickup terms, deposit, cleaning requirements, damage responsibility, insurance and late return rules. Ask what counts as normal wear versus damage. Ask what happens if the machine breaks down through no fault of yours, and whether rental time is credited. Ask whether rental payments can apply toward a later purchase. Request written quotes with everything itemized.

Ask about support and training

A rental is only as good as the support behind it. Ask whether the dealer walks you through operation and safety, provides manuals and offers a number for service help. Ask how fast they respond to breakdowns during planting or harvest. Ask whether they offer delivery, and whether technicians will come out. Ask your insurance agent whether your farm policy covers rented equipment, and what you need to add. Check operator qualifications and safety requirements; OSHA and NIOSH have safety information for agriculture.

Weigh rent versus other choices

Compare rental against custom hire, sharing with neighbors and buying used. Consider how many days you'd use the equipment and the downtime cost of waiting. Iowa State Ag Decision Maker and farmdoc daily discuss machinery cost comparisons. Talk with your accountant about how rental expenses are treated; the IRS Publication 225 is the farmer's tax guide. Keep a record of each rental, including condition notes and photos at pickup and return.

Watch the calendar

Rental demand follows the season. Spring and fall fleets get picked over fast, so book early. Ask if the dealer takes reservations and whether they hold equipment with a deposit. Ask what happens if the rental you reserved isn't available on the day. A dealer with a backup plan, such as a substitute machine of equal size, is worth more than one with a lower rate and no guarantees. Keep a list of two dealers so you aren't stuck if one is out of stock.

If you rent several times a year, ask whether the dealer offers a rental account or a loyalty arrangement, and have the terms written down so you know what you're signing up for.

Ask for a copy of the delivery checklist as well, so you and the driver agree on attachments, hours and condition when the machine arrives.

Photograph the machine before you drive off, and again when you return it. A handful of pictures settles a lot of arguments.