How do I compare lease vs buy?

Line up the real numbers

FORT COLLINS, Colorado — Comparing a lease to a purchase comes down to putting both options on the same footing: total cost over the time you'll actually use the machine, what you can do with it at the end, and how each choice affects your taxes and cash flow. A low monthly payment can hide a big buyout or heavy use limits. A purchase can tie up money you need for inputs. Neither choice is right for every farm, so the work is in the comparison, not in the answer you hoped for going in.

Start with how you'll use the machine

Hours per year is the first question. A combine or planter that runs a few weeks a season is a different animal from a loader tractor that works daily. Leases often carry annual hour limits with a charge for overages, so estimate your real hours honestly, including the bad years. If use is steady and the machine will last a decade on your place, buying tends to look better. If use is seasonal, uncertain or heavy, a lease or a rental may fit better.

Ask yourself whether you want to keep this machine through its whole life or swap it out on a schedule.

Get both offers in writing

Ask the dealer and any lender for written quotes on the same machine and configuration: one for purchase with financing, one for lease. Read for these items:

Don't rely on verbal numbers. Rates and terms move, so the current figures are whatever the document in front of you says.

Compare total cost, not the payment

Build a simple sheet for each option over the same time period. For a purchase, count the down payment, financing charges, expected service costs and what you think the machine will be worth when you sell or trade it. For a lease, count every payment, any fees, the end-of-term cost if you keep it, and possible penalties for wear or overuse. Then compare the two totals. The farmdoc daily site and the Iowa State Ag Decision Maker pages offer worksheets and articles on machinery cost analysis that are worth borrowing from.

Don't skip the tax side

Ownership and leasing are treated differently for tax purposes, and the rules on depreciation and deductions change from time to time. Read IRS Publication 225, the Farmer's Tax Guide, then take your two quotes to a tax preparer who works with farms. Ask which option gives you the better result this year and which gives you the better result across the whole term. Cash flow matters just as much as the deduction: a deduction doesn't help if the payment strains your operating line.

Think about risk and flexibility

Leasing can limit your exposure to a machine's resale value, since you hand it back. It can also lock you into payments through a bad crop year. Owning gives you freedom to use it as hard as you like but leaves you holding the repair bills and the resale risk. Talk to your lender about how each option shows up on your balance sheet. The Farm Service Agency and a local ag lender can explain financing programs you might qualify for, which may change the purchase side of the math.

Make the call

Lay the two sheets next to each other. If the totals are close, pick the one that fits your cash flow and your use pattern. If they're far apart, find out why before you decide. And keep the paperwork: a lease you didn't read has a way of reading you at the end of the term.

Questions to settle before you sign

Before either contract goes on the table, sit down with your lender and write out answers to a few plain questions. How many seasons do you expect to keep running this machine? What's your plan if a crop year goes badly and the payment still comes due? Do you have the shop space, the skill or the dealer relationship to handle maintenance yourself, or would a lease that bundles service suit you better? If you're a beginning farmer, the beginning farmers page at farmers.gov lists programs that sometimes change what financing options look like. Take notes on each answer. The honest answers often point toward one option before the spreadsheet does.