How do I compare new vs used prices?
Same machine, fair numbers
LUBBOCK, Texas — Comparing a new machine against a used one is harder than it looks, because the sticker numbers describe two different things. A new machine comes with a warranty, the latest features, and zero hidden history. A used one comes with wear, unknown abuse, and a lower entry cost. The fair comparison is cost per useful year of work, not the figure on the windshield. I won't quote prices here because they swing with the market, the region, and the season, but the method below works anywhere.
Build the same list for both machines
Write down what each machine includes: attachments, tires, hydraulics, cab, guidance, and any extras. A new base model and a loaded used one are not the same purchase. Add delivery, setup, taxes, and any fees. Then do the same for the used machine, including anything you will need to replace right away, such as tires, belts, filters, or fluids. Get every figure in writing so you are comparing quotes, not memories.
Estimate the cost of owning it
Ownership cost has several pieces: what you pay up front, interest on any loan, repairs, downtime, insurance, fuel efficiency differences, and what the machine will be worth when you sell it. Extension economists publish worksheets for this. The Iowa State Ag Decision Maker site has machinery cost tools, and farmdoc daily covers machinery economics regularly. Plug your own hours of use into those, not a stranger's.
Price the risk of a breakdown
A used machine's real cost shows up at the worst time, usually during planting or harvest. Ask yourself what a week of downtime costs your operation in lost yield or late hay. If the answer is a lot, a newer machine or a strong warranty may be worth more than the savings. If the machine runs a few days a year, an older one may be perfectly sensible.
Check the used machine properly
Ask for service records, look at the hour meter against the wear on pedals and seats, and run fluid samples if the dealer allows it. Bring a mechanic you trust if the machine is expensive. Check for open recalls or service bulletins with the dealer.
Compare the financing side
Financing can change the answer. A used machine might carry a higher interest rate or shorter term than a new one, and sometimes the reverse is true. Ask each dealer for the full terms in writing and compare against what your local lender or the Farm Service Agency offers. Tax treatment matters as well; IRS Publication 225 explains depreciation and deductions for farmers, and a tax preparer can tell you how each option lands on your return.
Make the call
Look at resale and depreciation
New machines tend to lose value fastest in the first few years, while older ones lose it more slowly because someone else already absorbed the drop. That doesn't make used the winner every time. A machine with a strong resale record can give back much of what you paid when you sell it, and one with a weak record won't. Check recent local auction results and dealer listings for the model you want, and ask a dealer what similar machines have been bringing lately.
Count your hours honestly
The right choice depends on how much you'll use it. A machine you run a few hundred hours a year wears out faster than one that runs a few weeks a year, and the cost per hour falls as use goes up. Do the math with your own hours. If you hire custom work for the same job, compare ownership against the custom rate in your area. Your extension office can usually tell you what custom operators in your county charge, and the USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service publishes custom rate surveys in some states that are worth a look.
Line up the totals, decide which risks you can live with, and buy the one that pays you back in work done. A bargain that sits in the shop isn't a bargain. Get several written quotes and treat the cheapest one with the same suspicion as the most expensive.
