How do I trade in old equipment?

Know its value before you walk in

ABILENE, Texas — Trading in old equipment can be convenient, since one transaction handles both the new purchase and the old machine leaving the yard. But convenience sometimes costs money. To trade well, you need to know what your equipment is worth, present it honestly, and keep the trade separate from the purchase price so you can see what each really does. Here's a practical way to go about it.

Get an idea of value first

Look at what similar machines are listing for at dealers, auctions and online classifieds in your region. Compare model, age, hours and condition. Ask more than one dealer for an appraisal, and ask for it in writing. Dealers know that prices vary by season and demand, so a machine might be valued differently in different places and times. Your goal is a range, not one number.

Get the machine ready

A clean, serviced machine is easier to trade. Wash it, fix small problems, replace obviously worn parts if it's cost-effective, and gather the service records, manuals and keys. A machine with a record of regular maintenance tells the dealer it was cared for. Be honest about known problems, since inspection will find them anyway and a surprise can sour the deal.

Keep the numbers separate

When you negotiate, ask for three separate figures: the price of the new machine, the value of your trade, and the financing terms. A dealer can make a trade look generous by raising the new price, so seeing each piece separately lets you tell. Get everything in writing before you sign.

Compare selling it yourself

You might get more by selling privately or through an auction, but it takes time, advertising, showings and a willingness to deal with strangers. Compare the trade-in offer with what you might net after fees and effort. Also ask whether an auction company charges commission and what it covers. For some farmers the convenience is worth the difference.

Handle liens, titles and taxes

If you still owe on the machine, the lender holds a lien and it must be paid off as part of the deal. Ask the dealer how they handle payoff. Confirm you have the paperwork for ownership. Trade-ins and sales can have tax implications, including depreciation recapture, which you should check with a tax professional. IRS Publication 225 is the farmer's tax guide.

Think about timing

If a major repair is coming up, trading before it happens may make sense. If you can wait, a machine that's been serviced might fetch more. Compare ownership costs with tools at Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker and farmdoc daily.

If the purchase requires a loan, farmers.gov explains what USDA offers.

What dealers look at in a trade

Knowing how a dealer sees your machine helps you present it well. Dealers consider age, hours, condition, brand demand in the region, how fast they expect to resell it and what reconditioning it needs. A machine that needs little work and sells easily is worth more to them than one that will sit on the lot or need a big repair.

You can improve your position by providing a clear record: service receipts, a list of recent repairs and replacements, original manuals and any extra equipment that goes with it, such as weights, a loader or a quick-attach. Ask whether attachments that come with the tractor are valued separately.

Be ready for the dealer to point out problems. Listen, ask what they would fix and what it would cost, then compare to your own repair quotes. If you disagree with the appraisal, ask the dealer to explain how they reached it. You can also get a second opinion from another dealer or an auctioneer. Remember that you can say no and keep the machine, sell it elsewhere or wait for a better time.

A trade is a negotiation like any other. Know your number, keep the pieces apart and be willing to say no thanks.