Which brands have the best dealer networks?

Judge the dealer, not the logo

CEDAR RAPIDS, Iowa — Asking which brand has the best dealer network is a fair question, but there isn't a single answer, because the best network is the one that serves your farm. A brand with dealers everywhere may still have a weak shop near you, and a lesser-known line may have an excellent local dealer. So instead of ranking brands, here's how to evaluate the network available in your area and make a decision you can defend.

Define what a good network means for you

Write down what you need: a parts counter within a reasonable drive, service technicians who work on your equipment, field service during busy seasons, loaner machines, and a dealer who has been around a while. Different farms weigh these differently. A grain farmer values harvest-time parts speed. A small livestock operation may care more about a friendly shop that handles compacts.

Map the dealers near you

Look up the dealers for each brand you're considering and note distance, hours and what services they offer. Consider the second-closest dealer, too, in case your first choice is busy. Ask neighbors who use each brand how their dealer performs. Consistent comments from several farmers tell you more than any one story.

Ask the dealers the same questions

Call or visit each dealer and ask:

Their answers, and how they answer, are your data.

Consider resale and long-term support

Ask local dealers and auctioneers how well different machines hold value in your area. Resale can depend on local demand and the dealer network, so it varies. Also think about how long parts will be available for a model and whether the dealer supports older machines.

Don't forget independent shops and mixed fleets

Many farms run equipment from several makers. If so, a good independent shop or a multi-line dealer may matter as much as any one brand's network. Ask whether a shop services what you own.

Use independent information

Independent test data from the Nebraska Tractor Test Laboratory can help with performance comparisons. For the economic side of equipment decisions, see farmdoc daily and Iowa State's Ag Decision Maker. I won't make brand claims here, since networks change and differ by region. Check with your own neighbors and dealers.

Questions to ask your neighbors

Your neighbors are the best source of real information on a dealer network. Ask them practical questions: how long did the last repair take, did the dealer return calls, did the parts arrive when promised, and would they buy from the same place again? Ask what went wrong and how the dealer handled it, because every dealer has bad days and the response is what counts.

Ask older farmers, too. They have seen dealers come and go, and they remember who stood by customers in tough years. Ask about dealer changes, such as ownership transfers or consolidations, since a change in ownership can change service quality. Check whether a dealer you're considering has closed or merged locations nearby, which could affect how far you'd drive for parts.

Write down what you hear and look for patterns. When three or four people raise the same strength or complaint, it's probably real. You can also ask your Extension office or a local farm organization such as Farm Bureau whether members share dealer experiences. No brand ranking can tell you what your neighbors can.

Keep in mind that dealer networks change over time. Locations open and close, ownership shifts and technicians move on. A choice that looks right today should be rechecked every few years, especially before a large purchase. Ask your current dealer how long their key staff have been there, because experienced people are a big part of what a network really offers.

The best network is a short drive, a quick part and a shop that returns your call. The paint color is a distant fourth.