How to Buy Hay You Can Trust

Test it, weigh it, then pay

SALINA, Kansas — The safest way to buy hay is to buy it on a forage test and a scale weight, not on the look of the bale. Color and smell tell you something, but they can't tell you protein, energy, or nitrate. A pretty green bale can be thin on feed value, and a weathered-looking one can be fine for dry cows. The only way to know is a lab report from the lot you're actually buying.

Most hay trouble comes from two sources: buying by the bale when bales vary wildly in weight, and buying without knowing what the animals need. Fix those two and you've dodged most of the arguments that end with a handshake gone cold.

Know what your animals need first

A dry cow in mid-gestation can live on average grass hay. A lactating cow, a growing stocker, or a ewe carrying twins can't. Before you shop, get the nutrient targets for your class of livestock from your county extension office or from a source like Kansas State Research and Extension or Noble Research Institute. Write down the crude protein and energy (often listed as TDN) you need, then shop for hay that meets it without paying for more.

Paying premium money for alfalfa to feed dry cows is how a hay budget gets embarrassed.

Ask for a forage test, and read the sample honestly

Ask the seller for a recent lab analysis tied to the specific cutting and field you'll receive. If there isn't one, offer to pull a core sample yourself and pay for the test. A hay probe pulls cores from many bales, and a handful of cores from one bale is not a sample of the lot. Mix them, send them to a certified forage lab, and ask for moisture, crude protein, fiber, TDN or relative feed value, and nitrates if the hay is a summer annual like sudan or sorghum hybrids.

Your extension office can tell you which labs are used locally and how to take a decent sample.

Pay by the ton, and check the weight

Bale weights drift. Two round bales that look identical can differ by hundreds of pounds because of density, moisture, and bale size. Whenever you can, agree on price per ton at an agreed moisture and weigh loads on a certified truck scale. If that isn't practical, weigh a few random bales and work out a price per pound of dry matter. Compare offers that way and the cheap-looking ones sometimes aren't.

For a sense of regional pricing, check the hay reports published through USDA Agricultural Marketing Service market news. They describe how hay is selling by region and quality class, and the numbers change often, so read the current report rather than trusting last season's number. AgMRC also collects forage marketing information.

Inspect the lot before it's on your trailer

Walk the stack. You're looking for:

Ask what the hay was baled at for moisture, and how long it's been stored. Hay stored outside on bare ground loses a surprising share of feed value from the bottom and the outside, so ask how it was kept.

Put the deal in writing

Even a friendly deal deserves a short written note: price, quantity or weight basis, species and cutting, the test result you're relying on, delivery terms, and what happens if the hay is not as described. If you're buying out of state, ask about noxious weed rules and any inspection paperwork your state requires. Your state department of agriculture is the place to check, and hay sold across state lines can come with extra requirements.

Pay on delivery, not on a promise, unless you know the seller well. A good seller won't mind.

Keep a log for next year

Write down who you bought from, the test results, what it cost per ton, and how your animals did on it. The animals' body condition is the final test. After one winter you'll know whose hay actually performed, and that's worth more than any ad. If you ever get short, a farm bureau chapter or your extension office can often point you to a local hay listing or exchange, which beats driving three counties on a rumor.